[問題]OG-131(主詞移轉概念淺述)

[skull]

(重貼) 先前那個無法編輯了

題目:
The commerce Department announced that economy grew during the second quarter at a 7.5 percent annual rate, while inflation eased when it might have been expected for it to rise.

正解B
The commerce Department announced that economy grew during the second quarter at a 7.5 percent annual rate, while inflation eased when it might have been expected to rise.

這個it是指inflation嗎?

想請問為何D)不行?

A)it might have been expected for it to rise
B)it might have been expected to rise
C)it might have been expected that it should rise
D) its rise might have been expected
E)there might have been an expectation it would rise

[GoldDigger]

D) its rise might have been expected
所有選擇中只有(D)的rise作名詞,改變了詞性,改變了句意
應依原句的to rise 表達動作

[agk99]

這是OG131

131.The Commerce Department announced that the economy grew during the second quarter at a 7.5 percent annual rate, while inflation eased when it might have been expected for it to rise.

(A) it might have been expected for it to rise
(B) it might have been expected to rise
(C) it might have been expected that it should rise
(D) its rise might have been expected
(E) there might have been an expectation it would rise

In English, x [is] expected to y is idiomatic usage: expected for it to in choice A and expected that it should in choice C are thus unidiomatic. Choice D awkwardly substitutes its rise for the pronoun it as the subject of might have been expected; since it refers to inflation, the subject of the verb eased, it is preferable as the subject of might have been expected, the verb form corresponding to eased. Choice E is needlessly wordy, roundabout, and vague. Choice B is best.

只要是動詞用的對
動詞原則上是優先名詞使用的

[liwuu]

Dear skull
給個小小的建議...請問您是否OG尚未看還是未看熟?!
因為看你問的這一兩個題目標題是寫考古題,不過卻是OG裡面的題目
我的重點不在這樣post題不行,而是建議您先將OG裡面的題目與後面解釋優先好好看熟再去做其他題目,這樣子準備起來效果會比較好唷!!參考看看...

[davidlee0222]

AGK老大真是太有心了

In English, x [is] expected to y is idiomatic usage: expected for it to in choice A and expected that it should in choice C are thus unidiomatic. Choice D awkwardly substitutes its rise for the pronoun it as the subject of might have been expected; since it refers to inflation, the subject of the verb eased, it is preferable as the subject of might have been expected, the verb form corresponding to eased. Choice E is needlessly wordy, roundabout, and vague. Choice B is best.

這串解答講D到底如何錯呢?
可能有不少人看了半天變丈二金剛
小弟解釋看看

這裡講的是"主軸一貫"的"主動"概念
有兩個概念
一是主軸一貫
二是主動
小弟在歐機中幾乎沒看到
主軸的主辭移轉有哪一提是對的

另外在簡潔概念中
"字少"不一定簡潔
"主動"永遠比"字少"重要
"不必要的被動"即使字少也被視為不簡潔
補習班沒有教
但歐雞詳解裡到處都有
越後面越多

後面while那句開始
主軸在講inflation
後面補述直接用it代inflation使主軸一貫
若是D
解答講一長串看不懂
就是在講主軸被移轉了
好端端的inflation到後面變成"它的提升"
所以awkward

另外D也是不必要的被動
在歐雞中
主軸一貫的"主辭"
去進行一個"動作"
永遠是最direct的表達方式
要比字的多寡基本上
只有兩句話都是"主辭"在主動進行"動作"時
才會比長短
但小弟目前也幾乎沒看過這樣的選項比較
都是被動或主辭移轉居多

而為何主辭移轉不簡潔呢?
因為同花順最大
中間變出個鬼牌插花就破功了

[agk99]

我把標題改一下，直接設定你為精華
大衛兄出手，真是不得了

[skull]

感謝agk99大哥的耐心解答

謝謝liwuu的提示

由於我只上過單元班 莫老只講考古題
至今未做過OG
不曉得原來大家都討論過了 (在OG裡)

看來從OG開始做題目比較好~

不好意思 很多不懂的地方
請大家見諒及指教~~


謝謝!

[魚]

感謝agk99大哥的耐心解答

謝謝liwuu的提示

由於我只上過單元班 莫老只講考古題
至今未做過OG
不曉得原來大家都討論過了 (在OG裡)

看來從OG開始做題目比較好~

不好意思 很多不懂的地方
請大家見諒及指教~~

報告 i57 ~ skull (妹妹) : 事情是醬滴 ! 因為總複習班裡前半段是觀念教學.後半段是OG題目的檢討. 所以莫老師的單元班,只上考古題
其實,無所謂好不好的問題.不過先從OG下手,尤其是徹底了解ETS提供的解釋,能讓考生更貼近ETS他的出提概念跟原則 ! 對於能力的提升會有較大的助益 ^^

站上OG 的提問連結還不夠完整, 有賴你多多"貢獻"嚕
加油 祝你成功

[skull]

謝謝魚哥哥的鼓勵~


慢慢看完OG的解釋 再腦中思考及理解它
滿有幫助的
(不過真的很花時間..)

可能要多點慧根, 才能快且準地catch OG解釋想表達的..

[cocaine]

:laugh 謝謝魚哥哥的鼓勵~


慢慢看完OG的解釋 再腦中思考及理解它
滿有幫助的
(不過真的很花時間..)

可能要多點慧根, 才能快且準地catch OG解釋想表達的..

你可以去下載區..那邊有熊妹的筆記.
我覺得你可以順便對著看..相信幫助會粉大..

[davidlee0222]

魚哥哥ㄝ
原來魚大隱藏身份這麼久~

歐雞詳解字字珠璣
若能看董必有七百牛人實力
有不懂請多多提問

另外任何難句問題可至RC版的難句諮詢中提問