考古題 form 26 #19

[Jackson0317]

19) Ralph Ellision and Amiri Baraka both argued that music was perhaps the ultimate expression of Afro-American culture, that it was the one vector of Afircan culture that there was no possibility to eradicate

a) that it was the one vector of Afircan culture that there was no possibility to eradicate
b) the one vector of African culture that could not be eradicted
c) for it was the one vector of Afircan culture, and that it was impossible to eradicate.
d) a vector of Afircan culture that there was no possibility to eradicate
e) as being the one vector that could not be eradicated from African culture.

Ans: B

所有答案真的只有B最好,但是有一個問題. 這題基本上是考Parallel (連接詞and刪除家comma), 但是如果只細看還是不夠平恆,我覺得少個that:

Ralph Ellision and Amiri Baraka both argued that..... , that one vector......

我想聽一下高手的看法.不知道我的概念是否ok.

[林小馬]

19) Ralph Ellision and Amiri Baraka both argued that music was perhaps the ultimate expression of Afro-American culture, that it was the one vector of Afircan culture that there was no possibility to eradicate

b) the one vector of African culture that could not be eradicted

Ans: B

所有答案真的只有B最好,但是有一個問題. 這題基本上是考Parallel (連接詞and刪除家comma), 但是如果只細看還是不夠平恆,我覺得少個that:

Ralph Ellision and Amiri Baraka both argued that..... , that one vector......

我想聽一下高手的看法.不知道我的概念是否ok.

我以為這題不是考PARALLEL耶~~
我說說看我的想法喔

B代入
Ralph Ellision and Amiri Baraka both argued that music was perhaps the ultimate expression of Afro-American culture, the one vector of African culture that could not be eradicted.
我自己看是覺得紅色部分整個都是在講
the ultimate expression of Afro-American culture
也就是music (因為兩個相等)

所以agrue that 後面的子句是一直包含到句尾的

高手幫忙指教一下囉~~~

[維尼]

同意小馬妹的看法
這邊的 the one vector ... 比較像是所謂的同位語

[Jackson0317]

真不愧是高手,這樣make sense.
不過我一個小問題,同位語的structure能有動詞嗎?

[維尼]

真不愧是高手,這樣make sense.
不過我一個小問題,同位語的structure能有動詞嗎?

同位語不是一個獨立子句
應該不會有動詞
像本題裡面是有 that關代子句 修飾同位語 the one vector of ....