[問題]987大全--Q635

[Aileen]

635. Several recent studies suggest that a child born into a family whose members have allergies will probably themselves develop allergies following the onset of a minor viral infection.
(A) a child born into a family whose members have allergies will probably themselves develop allergies
(B) children born into families whose members have allergies will probably themselves develop allergies
(C) a child born into a family the members of which have allergies will probably develop an allergy
(D) in those families where members have allergies, children will probably develop allergies themselves
(E) children born into a family in which there are allergies will themselves probably develop an allergy

Key:(B)
我選(C)，覺得(B)怪怪的，themselves為何可用在助動詞和動詞之間？families可用whose代嗎?
(C)錯在哪裡？

再麻煩高手們回答嚕~~3Q~

[Pufa]

themselves為何可用在助動詞和動詞之間？

themselves Longman
1
used to show that the people who do something are affected by their own action
Teachers have no choice but to take measures to protect themselves. Our neighbours have just bought themselves a jacuzzi.
The kids seem very pleased with themselves.
2
used to emphasize the pronoun 'they', a plural noun etc
Doctors themselves are the first to admit the treatment has side effects.
3
used after words like 'everyone', 'anyone', 'no one' etc when you talk about someone already mentioned and you do not know what sex they are or it is not important.
Many teachers think this is not correct English
Someone told me they'd actually seen the accident happen themselves.

families可用whose代嗎?

可以壓，人和物用whose。

(C)錯在哪裡？

a child born into a family (that) the members of which have allergies will probably develop an allergy.
跟B比起來，C塞兩個子句太囉唆啦，而且就算要這樣修飾，of也得刪掉才行。

[Aileen]

PUFA說到
themselves為何可用在助動詞和動詞之間
themselves Longman
1
used to show that the people who do something are affected by their own action
Teachers have no choice but to take measures to protect themselves. Our neighbours have just bought themselves a jacuzzi.
The kids seem very pleased with themselves.
2
used to emphasize the pronoun 'they', a plural noun etc
Doctors themselves are the first to admit the treatment has side effects.
3
used after words like 'everyone', 'anyone', 'no one' etc when you talk about someone already mentioned and you do not know what sex they are or it is not important.
Many teachers think this is not correct English
Someone told me they'd actually seen the accident happen themselves.

還是不太能理解此題themselves為什麼放在助動詞和動詞之間？因為一般themselves都放在主詞後面或句尾耶∼∼
再麻煩高手們指點迷津囉...3Q

[Behemoth]

簡單的說
就是英文中也有此用法
只是可能妳比較少用吧
所以覺得不習慣

這種用法你可以把他看成強調用法
強調是他們自己

妳有這點疑惑想必是因為莫老說的助動詞與動詞間不能加東西
不過像這種強調用法不在此限

[agk99]

themselves 既然可以放前放
就不是考點
恐怕你仍得從其他地方找錯

[freshmanduke]

除themselves外, each 也可這樣使用
refer to 天山7-31
they would each need a VIsa,a landing card,and evidence of inoculation against typhoid fever.

[維尼]

(C)錯在哪裡？

a child born into a family (that) the members of which have allergies will probably develop an allergy.
跟B比起來，C塞兩個子句太囉唆啦，而且就算要這樣修飾，of也得刪掉才行。

ㄛ..
這邊的 which 不就是代替 family 嗎?
為什麼會需要一個 that 呢? @_@

我是選C
1.
因為劃線後面有提到 allergy following the onset of a viral infection
所以覺得 allergy 用複數有點怪怪的
2.
From Longman:
For younger members of the family, there is an outdoor play area.
我覺得 the member of which (which 代替 a family) 是可以接受的用法

唯一可以說服我選B的原因是
原題有 themselves
答案C沒有 改變句意

[freshmanduke]

若真要選C C應該改成

C) a child born into a family, the members of which have allergies, will probably develop an allergy
需加兩個comma 在the members of which have allergies間
而且我覺得這是敘述一個普遍的現象
用複數表示較為適當

[維尼]

若真要選C C應該改成

C) a child born into a family, the members of which have allergies, will probably develop an allergy
需加兩個comma 在the members of which have allergies間
而且我覺得這是敘述一個普遍的現象
用複數表示較為適當

可是這樣子的改法
不就把限定子句改成非限定子句了?
句意不就完全改變了?!

[小真真]

哎呀 我剛po錯文章了啦