[問題]天山-3-Q30

[twkevin]

天山-3-30
Q30:
Unlike that of earlier works on slavery, Blassingame’s innovative study relies not on the records of White slave owners but on the records of the salves themselves, especially the 70 or so autobiographies and memoirs that have been preserved.

A. that of earlier works on slavery, Blassingame’s
B. that of earlier works on slavery, Blassingame in his
C. earlier works on slavery, Blassingame in his
D. earlier works on slavery, Blassingame’s
E. the earlier works on slavery, Blassingame in his
ANS: (A)
大家是如何排除(D)

[Calvin]

D is wrong since they think works is not the same as study.

So works and study are uncomparable.

but i doubt about that...

FYI

[agk99]

平衡講求單數對單數 名詞對名詞
所以works 無法和 study比較
反而是that = study，就對了

[davidlee0222]

??
works就是study說
答案有沒有錯???

請問that要指誰??
records嗎
這樣比較就不同類啦
如果不是that就無人能指了
因為that也是要講work

英文裡study算是一種work或effort
當指"研究工作"時
三者是同意字

"不像早期的諸多研究，B的研究..."
D無敵平衡的說
A完全不知that在講誰redundancy
work就已經等於study

[Ethan]

哇哈哈哈.......................

[davidlee0222]

?
你午安ㄋㄨㄚˋ某??

[bugubugu]

還原(A)原句:
Unlike that (代study) of earlier works on slavery, Blassingame’s innovative study relies not on the records of White slave owners but on the records of the salves themselves, especially the 70 or so autobiographies and memoirs that have been preserved.

that (study) 和study同類....
works和study不同類....
所以(A)對...

這study所仰賴得the records是指slaves的autobiographies and memoirs

若選(D)選項:
Unlike earlier works on slavery, Blassingame’s innovative study relies not on the records of White slave owners but on the records of the salves themselves, especially the 70 or so autobiographies and memoirs that have been preserved.
不同類且不合句意...

[Ethan]

哇哈哈哈....................... ;yes;
真的很好!

[kikisky]

ethan大哥~
別光顧著孝啦~
出手解答啦~~~

快點啦~~

[agk99]

哈哈哈哈

答案改成D比較好　這次我同意大衛
就句意來說應該是D會比較通

[cocaine]

哈哈哈哈

答案改成D比較好　這次我同意大衛
就句意來說應該是D會比較通

我也覺得是D,那個that改成those我還覺得差不多...
不然我覺得works跟study意義一樣,都是指研究報告..

[bugubugu]

哈哈哈哈

答案改成D比較好　這次我同意大衛
就句意來說應該是D會比較通

大哥...
study(研究)和works(著作)的確不同類哩...
這題(A)句意是說...
不像早期對works的研究...
B這人他革新的研究並非仰賴白人而是仰賴黑奴的records...
這意味著works是白人寫的/講的...
而records是黑奴寫的/講的...

[cocaine]

哈哈哈哈

答案改成D比較好　這次我同意大衛
就句意來說應該是D會比較通

大哥...
study(研究)和works(著作)的確不同類哩...
這題(A)句意是說...
不像早期對works的研究...
B這人他革新的研究並非仰賴白人而是仰賴黑奴的records...
這意味著works是白人寫的/講的...
而records是黑奴寫的/講的...

that of earlier works 不是應該改成 those of earlier works
works是粉多的...
而且我覺得work跟study都學術上的研究,work可以當study的集合.
列如說一系列研究的著作

[bugubugu]

that of earlier works 不是應該改成 those of earlier works
works是粉多的...
而且我覺得work跟study都學術上的研究,work可以當study的集合.
列如說一系列研究的著作

因為這句的study就是只有一個subject:
在slave這方面的study

不像對早期works在slave這方面的研究, B這人在slave這方面的革新研究仰賴黑奴的records而非白人records....

[魚]

神人 E老大又出世了啊 !!

萬民之福