[問題]考古題form22-Q2

[cleashen]

Tecumseh urged all Native American tribes, even former enemies, to resist the cession of individual parcels of land by forming an international confederacy and under it there will be common ownership of all tribal lands.

(B)that all Native American tribes, and even former enemies, resist the cession of individual parcels of land by forming an international confederacy and under it there would be

(C)that all Native American tribes, even former enemies, should to resist the cession of individual parcels of land by forming an international confederacy and under it they would have

(D)all Native American tribes, even former enemies, to resist the cession of individual parcels of land by forming an international confederacy and under it there would be

(E)all Native American tribes, and even former enemies, that they to were to resist the cession of individual parcels of land, form an international confederacy, and under it they would have

不好意思 這題題目真是密密麻麻~

我想請問的是 我記得urge最常見的用法是
urge that+主詞+ (should省略)+原型V
可是這題的答案(D)卻完全不符合此規定
請問一下是不是有其他的用法呢??
其他的選項又是錯在哪裡呢??
不知道各位高手是怎麼解這題的??
感謝大家!

[林小馬]

不好意思 這題題目真是密密麻麻~

我想請問的是 我記得urge最常見的用法是
urge that+主詞+ (should省略)+原型V
可是這題的答案(D)卻完全不符合此規定
請問一下是不是有其他的用法呢??
其他的選項又是錯在哪裡呢??
不知道各位高手是怎麼解這題的??
感謝大家!

哈哈 我終於有一題可以回答了
(大部分都回答不出來 哈哈)
因為本來就有
urge sb to V的用法啦
字典上說
He urged that we should go.
= He urged us to go.
所以標準選項D就是這個用法啦

其他的問題
A, will有問題
B, 這邊的even former enemies是Native American tribes的同味語
所以不應該有and
如果有and, 這個former enemies到底是誰沒講清楚,而且前面不該有逗號
C, should to有問題, 另一個問題同B
而且ETS中,should的省略幾乎都省
E, 沒有urge sb that they to V這個綜合兩個用法的東西

大家幫忙指正一下喔
感謝感謝
埃 我考古題很多都不會
會的大大就多回答幾題吧

[cleashen]

耶耶~感謝您 懂了懂了!!!
不勝感激!!

[uu3540]

請問除了正確答案 其他選項都是有and under it 這裡的代名詞it對象清楚嗎??

[dibert8]

it = confederacy

[dibert8]

在 (B) (D) 之間掙扎,差別在 all Native American tribes 在 (B) 是主格, 在 (D) 是受格,
如果是主格 ", and even former enemies," 冒出來就不知道是誰的 enemies ,(試想句子一開頭 All Native American tribes, and even former enemies, 可以知道 enemies 指誰嗎?) 事實上 all Native American tribes 已包含 former enemies, 所以 ", and even former enemies," 在句意上是多餘的.
如果是受格 ", even former enemies," 是 tribes 的同位語, 這些部落即使之前是敵人,附加說明的意味很明顯,因此有插入這結構的正當性.
所以選 (D) 了.