請問GWD24-Q1

[u9069700]

24-1 Tom Bradley was mayor of Los Angeles from 1973 to 1993, an era when the city had transformed from a collection of suburban neighborhoods to the second-largest city in the United States.
(A) an era when the city had transformed
(B) an era during which the city was transformed
(C) an era that transformed it
(D) during which era the city transformed
(E) during which the city was transformed
答案是B
請問一下介係詞+關代的用法，前面是不是一定要有N,不可以像D.E選項降，逗號後直接加介係詞+關代
再請問A選項是錯在時態嗎?用when 應該是沒問題八(when=during which)

可以說明一下嗎---感謝感謝~~ :D

[micht]

24-1 Tom Bradley was mayor of Los Angeles from 1973 to 1993, an era when the city had transformed from a collection of suburban neighborhoods to the second-largest city in the United States.
(A) an era when the city had transformed
(B) an era during which the city was transformed
(C) an era that transformed it
(D) during which era the city transformed
(E) during which the city was transformed
答案是B

(A)肯定錯 絕對不可以用when


這題看句意比較快解...

同位語
1973 to 1993, an era when the city had transformed

when=當
during=某段時間 a period of time
1973 to 1993 是一段時間 不是某個時間的"當下"

如果要選D,E的話 during前面就不要加(,)逗點


有錯請指正~~個人想法

[agk99]

同意micht
理由是when表達不出一段期間
加上若是選A，會導致變化在先，當市長在後，題意不對

[u9069700]

喔~~~i see i see

3Q

[bugubugu]

如果要選D,E的話 during前面就不要加(,)逗點

有錯請指正~~個人想法

為何不能加逗號?
我選E耶...

[bugubugu]

如果要選D,E的話 during前面就不要加(,)逗點

有錯請指正~~個人想法

為何不能加逗號?
我選E耶...

我自問自答好了...
我發現用during which有指代錯誤...
因為which應該是不能代from1973 to 1993...
所以要加個an era比較清楚...

就醬...

[ivanchiang]

之前自己在某篇回文裡提到過
"when"用來代表某一時間點比較貼切
結果今天自己在做這題時又犯了這大忌
說說這題的細解吧

(A)如上所說，when的用法不貼切；另外city被transform的講法比較好；還有from~to~首選一般過去式
(B)完美答案！an era清楚指到from 1973 to 1993，which清楚指到an era，city被transform
(C)it，就是那個it
(D)which看不出是在指什麼，city自己transform了
(E)which問題同(D)