[問題]GWD-11-19

[cuteone]

那我想請問
E.like much of Eastern Europe, an overwhelming proportion of women work, many are in

1.前面的部分: like 後如果加 in 就對了吧?(比較同類)
2.逗號後面為何不能改能many of them are in......?
are 為何要去除呢? 兩者意思有何差別?

[Behemoth]

1.是的
2.若有are,則兩個句子中間少連接詞變流水句囉

[cocaine]

q19 In Hungary, as in much of Eastern Europe, an overwhelming proportion of women work, many of which are in middle management and light industry.




A. as in much of Eastern Europe, an overwhelming proportion of women work, many of which are in

B. as with much of Eastern Europe, an overwhelming proportion of women works, many in
C. as in much of Eastern Europe, an overwhelming proportion of women work, many of them in
D. like much of Eastern Europe, an overwhelming proportion of women works, and many are
D. like much of Eastern Europe, an overwhelming proportion of women work, many are in


這題答案是C,不過我發現如果是C的話,我找不到這個句子的主要動詞
這題究竟在考什麼觀念阿???

這題考比較,同位語
C最後一段是說many of them in xxxxxxxxxx
them就是說women

[cocaine]

much 應該是修飾Eastern Europe
在大部分的東歐地區
有錯請指正

認同V大分析,
Hungary跟大部分的東歐地區做比較

[DARY]

我想請問 莫老師說as當"像"來說時,as+s+v 但是這句話as in much of Eastern Europe 並無任何動辭阿??? 還是這句話不是這個觀念

因為它是省略舊的資訊....
as they(women) do(work) in much of Eastern Europe...
其實莫老師還有一個規則...
就是
連+(1)介+名 , S+V....
(2)分詞
(3)形
(4)名

不過我是覺得他規則太多....
有時用了反而會誤解....
建議自己整理規則...

我想另外請問一下..若是還原成上述句子,那麼much表示什麼意思呢?
若不是還原成上述句子,那麼much又代表什麼呢?
謝謝

我也覺得much在這邊用的怪怪的

如果指的是 大部分東歐地區

是不是用 as in many countries of Eastern Europe （或是像 most parts of the Eastern Europe）比較順一點
用much...怪怪的...

不過五個答案都是用much 看來沒得挑

那野按咧 .....

試著將本句還原
As (women work) in much of Eastern Europe, an overwhelming propotion of women work in Hungary, many of them in middle management and light industry.

請問逗號之後的文法結構是如何啊??

[DARY]

我想請問 莫老師說as當"像"來說時,as+s+v 但是這句話as in much of Eastern Europe 並無任何動辭阿??? 還是這句話不是這個觀念

因為它是省略舊的資訊....
as they(women) do(work) in much of Eastern Europe...
其實莫老師還有一個規則...
就是
連+(1)介+名 , S+V....
(2)分詞
(3)形
(4)名

不過我是覺得他規則太多....
有時用了反而會誤解....
建議自己整理規則...

我想另外請問一下..若是還原成上述句子,那麼much表示什麼意思呢?
若不是還原成上述句子,那麼much又代表什麼呢?
謝謝

我也覺得much在這邊用的怪怪的

如果指的是 大部分東歐地區

是不是用 as in many countries of Eastern Europe （或是像 most parts of the Eastern Europe）比較順一點
用much...怪怪的...

不過五個答案都是用much 看來沒得挑

那野按咧 .....

試著將本句還原
As (women work) in much of Eastern Europe, an overwhelming propotion of women work in Hungary, many of them in middle management and light industry.

請問逗號之後的文法結構是如何啊??

呼呼!!有第二頁說....是同位語..
頭昏了!!該睡了

[James]

q19 In Hungary, as in much of Eastern Europe, an overwhelming proportion of women work, many of which are in middle management and light industry.

A. as in much of Eastern Europe, an overwhelming proportion of women work, many of which are in

B. as with much of Eastern Europe, an overwhelming proportion of women works, many in
C. as in much of Eastern Europe, an overwhelming proportion of women work, many of them in
D. like much of Eastern Europe, an overwhelming proportion of women works, and many are
D. like much of Eastern Europe, an overwhelming proportion of women work, many are in

這題答案是C

in是不是不能省?

[wangdaven]

當然不能, 別忘了比較一定一定要同類

[邁向高等學府]

這題我不選C的原因，是因為many of them, 我想many of whom 不是較佳嗎？若用many of them 會不會有流水句的可能？還是many of them 其實是women的同位語？
麻煩大家
謝謝

看了前輩的討論：突然了解了…
不好意思…來插花

[yuying]

這題是同位語 還是獨立主格結構(獨立分詞) ? 我覺得應該是後者….
An overwhelming proportion of women works, and many of them are in middle management and light industry.
省略and和are. 主詞不同保留
同位語是用來補充說明前面的名詞, 不太可能直接接在動詞後面吧….
誰可以來幫忙回答一下 謝謝

[laveus]

agree to 獨立主格構句 .
另外 還是覺得much 的用法很怪哩....
有沒有什麼使用上的條件 ??

[christina]

關於as/like的比較用法,
今天再看一次OG126解釋,有提到在做比較時,as慣用當連接詞後接附屬子句,而like 慣用當介系詞,成為介系詞片語,
根據解釋,
我在想如果即使E選改為like in much of EE,..
也是錯的吧,
不知這樣的想法對不對,請教各位大大~
謝謝!!

[CUGGYER]

想請問這題 (C) 應該怎麼還原原句?

還有我對這題薄弱的了解是否正確
A 看不出錯哪裡 只覺得which很怪
B as 不對稱 應該用 as in
D be動詞平衡 women =/= industry , like 不對稱 地點/人比
E like不對稱

答案是C 不會還原 有點不知道什麼意思

這題我幾乎摸不著頭緒 ><
原本我還是用 LIKE接名詞 AS接S+V去做 勉強選e....

[林小馬]

q19
In Hungary, as in much of Eastern Europe, an overwhelming proportion of women work, many of which are in middle management and light industry.

A. as in much of Eastern Europe, an overwhelming proportion of women work, many of which are in
C. as in much of Eastern Europe, an overwhelming proportion of women work, many of them in

這題都沒有人選A嗎
為什麼我每次都選到很奇怪的答案啦~~~~~ :(

我沒有選C是因為
我在想那是不是應該要用many of whom啊
因為我實在沒有看過後半句這樣的用法
還是有哪個OG很熟的大大幫忙指點一下
(因為我還沒有看熟到可以引經據典啊)

我不覺得是用同位語耶
比如說many of the students就絕對不是the students的同位語啊
因為前者是後者的一部分啊
我是這樣猜測的

A的話我也很討厭那個which
可是我在想有沒有可能是指proportion啊
因為前面a overwhelming proportion of women
畢竟of women只是修飾proportion
proportion才是真正的主辭 所以就用which囉
雖然覺得用many和are也很討厭
可是既然work都用複數動辭了 大概就是當複數用吧

其實我也不喜歡A啦 可是覺得C也有點詭異
有人可以再幫忙指教一下嗎

[Pufa]

q19 In Hungary, as in much of Eastern Europe, an overwhelming proportion of women work, many of which are in middle management and light industry.

A. as in much of Eastern Europe, an overwhelming proportion of women work, many of which are in
C. as in much of Eastern Europe, an overwhelming proportion of women work, many of them in

我沒有選C是因為
我在想那是不是應該要用many of whom啊
因為我實在沒有看過後半句這樣的用法
還是有哪個OG很熟的大大幫忙指點一下
(因為我還沒有看熟到可以引經據典啊)

用word查，一下子就知道了。
gwd2-12
gwd9-23

我不覺得是用同位語耶
比如說many of the students就絕對不是the students的同位語啊
因為前者是後者的一部分啊
我是這樣猜測的

是同位語沒錯。
同位語的數量不一定要跟他修飾的對象數量相同，
簡單的說，只要能起修飾作用就可以了。

A的話我也很討厭那個which
可是我在想有沒有可能是指proportion啊
因為前面a overwhelming proportion of women
畢竟of women只是修飾proportion
proportion才是真正的主辭 所以就用which囉
雖然覺得用many和are也很討厭
可是既然work都用複數動辭了 大概就是當複數用吧

proportion還是單數，所以which後面還是得跟單數動詞才行。
work用複數動詞？
這裡的work是動詞喔！