[問題]天山-3-Q30

由 **micht** » 2005-02-19 22:37

Calvin \$m[1]:D is wrong since they think works is not the same as study.

So works and study are uncomparable.

but i doubt about that...

FYI

是!!

天山-3-30
Q30:
Unlike that of earlier works on slavery, Blassingame’s innovative study relies not on the records of White slave owners but on the records of the salves themselves, especially the 70 or so autobiographies and memoirs that have been preserved.

A. that of earlier works on slavery, Blassingame’s
B. that of earlier works on slavery, Blassingame in his
C. earlier works on slavery, Blassingame in his
D. earlier works on slavery, Blassingame’s
E. the earlier works on slavery, Blassingame in his
ANS: (A)

兩份研究報告(study)是在研究早期關於奴隸的報告(earlier works on slavery)
這裡的that指study, not work (they are not the same and not comparable)

只是後來的研究報告(study) 採用的工具不是白人的 record 而是奴隸自己本身的 records

總結是: 前study採用白人record, Blassingame's 則採用奴隸自己的record來去探討研究早期關於奴隸的報告

SO, (A) is definately the answer

D is wrong indeed.

由 **cocaine** » 2005-02-19 22:52

micht \$m[1]:
Calvin \$m[1]:D is wrong since they think works is not the same as study.

So works and study are uncomparable.

but i doubt about that...

FYI

是!!

天山-3-30
Q30:
Unlike that of earlier works on slavery, Blassingame’s innovative study relies not on the records of White slave owners but on the records of the salves themselves, especially the 70 or so autobiographies and memoirs that have been preserved.

A. that of earlier works on slavery, Blassingame’s
B. that of earlier works on slavery, Blassingame in his
C. earlier works on slavery, Blassingame in his
D. earlier works on slavery, Blassingame’s
E. the earlier works on slavery, Blassingame in his
ANS: (A)

兩份研究報告(study)是在研究早期關於奴隸的報告(earlier works on slavery)
這裡的that指study, not work (they are not the same and not comparable)

只是後來的研究報告(study) 採用的工具不是白人的 record 而是奴隸自己本身的 records

總結是: 前study採用白人record, Blassingame's 則採用奴隸自己的record來去探討研究早期關於奴隸的報告

SO, (A) is definately the answer

D is wrong indeed.

恩..我認同了..句意後面有說一個用白人一個用黑奴..
所以早期是特定.其中白人研究..
A是正確的...這題還繞~~~

由 **Calvin** » 2005-02-19 23:24

敢問micht

如果我翻成

不像早期相關奴隸的學術著作（要翻研究報告也可，whatever），B的研究報告不是著重在 x 而是 Y

早期奴隸的學術著作是著重在Y，現在B的報告研究方法是著重在Y

這樣可以嗎？

我實在看不出不能用D的道理！

請繼續討論

由 **cocaine** » 2005-02-19 23:34

Calvin \$m[1]:敢問micht

如果我翻成

不像早期相關奴隸的學術著作（要翻研究報告也可，whatever），B的研究報告不是著重在 x 而是 Y

早期奴隸的學術著作是著重在Y，現在B的報告研究方法是著重在Y

這樣可以嗎？

我實在看不出不能用D的道理！

請繼續討論

我覺得是研究題材的比較..
不像早期著作的研究題材,B的創新研究題材是以黑奴紀錄(題材)....
這樣我覺得蠻ok蠻對稱的

請繼續討論

由 **reohuang** » 2005-02-20 01:31

我個人prefer D選項也 *-)

A) that of early works (on slavery) 跟 B's innovative study的比較
D) early works (on slavery) 跟 B's innovative study的比較

從句意上來看好像選項D)的：不同於以往對於slavery的研究，B對於slavery的研究採用不同的內容比較貼切

如果後面的比較對象是B採用的內容...那麼用A)的解釋：that of early works (on slavery) 來做比較對象就比較適當了

請繼續討論~

由 **micht** » 2005-02-20 03:30

報告大家
其實我本來也選到D...可是後來看看 A 也行ㄉ樣子
爭議的地方簡單來講就是
到底

study=workㄇ??? ^o)

此考點是兩個東西在比較
句意說明 study vs. study (一個用白人record,一個用奴隸record)

的確雖然 work 可以和study同意
但它也有別的意思但是 SC基本原則是 [highlight=yellow]清楚簡潔且正確[/highlight]

所以我想A雖然繞了一點但是似乎不會名詞解釋的爭議

請各位在看看 +o(

work
from Longman
▶JOB◀
[uncountable]a job or activity that you do regularly, especially in order to earn money
▶DUTIES◀
[uncountable]the duties and activities that are part of your job
▶RESULT◀
[uncountable] something that you produce as a result of doing your job or doing an activity
▶ACTIVITY◀
[uncountable]when you use physical or mental effort in order to achieve something
▶STUDY◀
[uncountable]study or research, especially for a particular purpose

study
▶RESEARCH◀
[countable]a piece of work that is done to find out more about a particular subject or problem, and usually includes a written report
▶LEARNING◀
[uncountable] when you spend time learning, especially at home or by yourself rather than during school
Set aside a period of time specifically for study.

innovative
1. an innovative idea or way of doing something is new, different, and better than those that existed before
an innovative approach to language teaching

2 using clever new ideas and methods
an innovative design team

這題考比較
比較的不同點是 (一個用白人record,一個用奴隸record)

是兩個study採用的方法不同

Q30:
Unlike that of earlier works on slavery, Blassingame’s innovative study relies not on the records of White slave owners but on the records of the salves themselves, especially the 70 or so autobiographies and memoirs that have been preserved.

Q30:
Unlike earlier works on slavery, Blassingame’s innovative study relies not on the records of White slave owners but on the records of the salves themselves, especially the 70 or so autobiographies and memoirs that have been preserved.

總結是:

如果 work=study 不會混淆的話我會選(D) +o(

請繼續討論........... ^o)

由 **Pufa** » 2005-02-20 14:34

micht姐，
你舉的work都是uncountable的，和題目中的works不一樣喔。

1. ▶BOOK/PAINTING/MUSIC◀
[countable] something such as a painting, play, piece of music etc that is produced by a painter, writer, or musician
the Collected Works of Shakespeare.
It is another accomplished work by the artist.

2. works [plural, uncountable]
a) activities involved in building or repairing things such as roads, bridges etc
engineering works/irrigation works/roadworks
the official in charge of the engineering works
- see also public works
b)a building or group of buildings in which goods are produced in large quantities or an industrial process happens
ironworks/gasworks/cement works
The brick works closed last year

同樣是來自longman，大家參考一下。

由 **bugubugu** » 2005-02-20 20:04

其實我覺得(D)中的works若翻"研究"雖然意思通...
但和原句(A)的works句意就不一樣啦...

SC中若有改變句意的情形...
除非原題(A)句意有錯...
否則不能選的....
原句的works和records,autobiographies and memoirs ...
同為要研究的題材...
(D)的works就變成研究了....

SC和RC不同...
RC的話即使不同詞性都算同義...
但SC不同詞性就算改變句意了...

由 **micht** » 2005-02-21 10:46

天山-3-30
Q30:
Unlike that of earlier works on slavery, Blassingame’s innovative study relies not on the records of White slave owners but on the records of the salves themselves, especially the 70 or so autobiographies and memoirs that have been preserved.

A. that of earlier works on slavery, Blassingame’s
B. that of earlier works on slavery, Blassingame in his
C. earlier works on slavery, Blassingame in his
D. earlier works on slavery, Blassingame’s
E. the earlier works on slavery, Blassingame in his
ANS: (A)

這題回頭在看

句意
A) 兩個研究對過去某個對黑人研究進行比較
D) 兩個研究對黑人進行比較

到底是哪一個句意是這題目所想表達的呢?

由 **cocaine** » 2005-02-21 11:57

micht \$m[1]:天山-3-30
Q30:
Unlike that of earlier works on slavery, Blassingame’s innovative study relies not on the records of White slave owners but on the records of the salves themselves, especially the 70 or so autobiographies and memoirs that have been preserved.

A. that of earlier works on slavery, Blassingame’s
B. that of earlier works on slavery, Blassingame in his
C. earlier works on slavery, Blassingame in his
D. earlier works on slavery, Blassingame’s
E. the earlier works on slavery, Blassingame in his
ANS: (A)

這題回頭在看

句意
A) 兩個研究對過去某個對黑人研究進行比較
D) 兩個研究對黑人進行比較

到底是哪一個句意是這題目所想表達的呢?

innovative study 從這已該可以推出是要針對研究方式做一各變革..
所以A

由 **shopcat** » 2005-02-27 12:46

可是如果用that 不是應該要前面要有出現可以指代的事物
可是A卻是指代到後面才知道that指study
這樣的句子不是比較不漂亮嗎
我也是選D

由 **bugubugu** » 2005-02-27 13:22

shopcat \$m[1]:可是如果用that 不是應該要前面要有出現可以指代的事物
可是A卻是指代到後面才知道that指study
這樣的句子不是比較不漂亮嗎
我也是選D

這裡的that不是關代的that...
是單數代名詞取代原題主詞的that...
(複數用those...)

若是題目是which...
那的確就如你所說應該要前面要有出現可以指代的事物...

由 **liwuu** » 2005-02-27 13:22

很久沒看SC...不過我總覺得答案是A,那個"that"是指Blassingame這個人
句子說明這個人的前後研究的不同!!
有沒有人跟我同樣的想法呀?! ;-S

答案D無法說明到底是別的學者之前的研究,還是Blassingame這個學者之前的研究

由 **bugubugu** » 2005-02-27 22:22

liwuu \$m[1]:很久沒看SC...不過我總覺得答案是A,那個"that"是指Blassingame這個人
句子說明這個人的前後研究的不同!!
有沒有人跟我同樣的想法呀?!

答案D無法說明到底是別的學者之前的研究,還是Blassingame這個學者之前的研究

liwuu大哥你是不是不小心po錯了?
你是說that是代替Blassingame's study吧?
醬就會是你說的....
說明這個人的前後研究的不同...
若是代Blassingame這個人
會比較不同類喔....

网站 · 由 **agk99** » 2005-02-27 22:57

liwuu \$m[1]:很久沒看SC...不過我總覺得答案是A,那個"that"是指Blassingame這個人
句子說明這個人的前後研究的不同!!
有沒有人跟我同樣的想法呀?!

答案D無法說明到底是別的學者之前的研究,還是Blassingame這個學者之前的研究

這位大哥，你說that 指人?
我和bugu的看法一樣，願聞其詳

[問題]天山-3-Q30

在线用户