[問題]GWD12-1 (即9-1)

[odinhsu]

肯幫忙問的人好像不多..
這題已經放很久了也沒人問....

[blue123736]

這題之前跟讀書會的同伴有下課後去問過莫北北

B E哪一個好

他一看 就說這題很多人問過他

"B好
E不好 因為有being嘛 不是跟你說過B-E-I-N-G少選嗎
(接下好像來講一些機經東西不要太相信之類的話...)..........
a black american用在這邊會容易誤為三本小說由同一人寫的
（接下來再講一些有時間不如去練考古題跟OG之類的話...）...." :-S


因為這約略是十一月多的事啦
印象有一點模糊 :P
可能還有提到一些其他細節 但被我忘記了
所以這樣轉述可能有些難以服人
僅提出來供大家參考∼

[bugubugu]

"B好 E不好 因為有being嘛 不是跟你說過B-E-I-N-G少選嗎

覺得這句非常之傳神....

[micht]

慘了 ...這題><!! 令人抓狂
我剛剛瀏覽了一下收集的cd jj

有一個 760牛人出了這一題選 Ans: B
Verbal 44!!!!

另一個 760牛人 出了這一題 選 Ans: B
但他說他估計這題猜錯
因為緊接著出現的SC 劃線部分很短(但我覺得這又不能代表之前做錯 我到決得有些話線短的很難選呢??))
此人的 Verbal拿幾分我再查一下!!


這題))))))))

[micht]

報告大家 我找到連結了
兩位都是760大牛都選B

4.[原創]1月4日，二戰，760 M50 V44 午馬起行

http://forum.chasedream.com/dispbbs.asp ... 213&page=1

8.[原創]大連 760(機經) kane1979

http://forum.chasedream.com/dispbbs.asp ... 189&page=1

[bugubugu]

轉自simenchen 問莫老師的結果報告
http://www.formosamba.com/phpBB3/viewtopic.php?t=3080

[Calvin]

這題我考試也有碰到，我選 E

就b, e比較，e 還是較優的！

平衡，句意也清楚，至少b的破折號加including沒看過這種用法！

[clelia]

只是剛好看到。補充一下

OG裡有 " ─ including"這樣的用法哦~~

在RC 第二十八篇，講黑人在軍隊裡的那篇。就在第一句話裡

Joseph Glarthaar’s Forged in Battle is not the first excellent study of Black soldiers and their White officers in the Civil War, but it uses more soldiers’ letters and diaries—including rare material from Black soldiers—and concentrates more intensely on Black-White relations in Black regiments than do any of its predecessors.

所以不能用破折號後不能用including這樣的方法來排除選項。
不過我也強力支持E哦。
就像金鋼妹說的，談論的東西是作品，而且我覺得要談到三本的另外兩本，
用including沒有用the others (把先前講過的那本排除掉)好唄。

而且OG裡也常出現"being"這個字。只是很少出現在選項裡就是了。
所以不能說有being就不好吧~~~~~

[Calvin]

clelia舉的例子又與本題有不同之處

本題只有前有破折號，後面並沒有，這與RC裡面的用法是不同的！

RC裡這種前後用破折號的用法，是很常見的

[ian]

這題我以前考試有碰過，是考試第一題
我是猜E，看來答案是E
因為第二題馬上就變難

[Pudding]

我也覺得破折號在這邊不是關鍵...

"a black American" 可直接排除C/D/E (黑美人? 美黑人? 當機中.....)

[cafe]

這題答案是B還是Eㄚ????
我選B耶~~~

A mixture of poems and short fiction, Jean Toomer’s Cane has been called one of the three best novels ever written by Black Americans—the others being Richard Wright, author of Native Son, and Ralph Ellison, author of Invisible Man.

A.Black Americans—the others being Richard Wright, author of Native Son, and Ralph Ellison, author of Invisible Man
B.Black Americans—including Native Son by Richard Wright and Invisible Man by Ralph Ellison
C.a Black American—including Richard Wright, author of Native Son, and Ralph Ellison, author of Invisible Man
D.a Black American—the others being Richard Wright, author of Native Son, and Ralph Ellison, author of Invisible Man
E.a Black American—the others being Richard Wright’s Native Son and Ralph Ellison’s Invisible Man


另外, 由此題,我想問大家 ,including 和 that included 這兩個分別在哪 ?

答案應該是B
老莫解法
1.一秒解題法，比較長短,B最短。b對
2.最偉大的三本著作，不可能是只有ㄧ個人寫，更何況之後還有列舉另外兩各。所以用a black的都錯。CDE出局。
3.Being少選，A用being 句子又比較長，答案B的機率提高。再者，and連結兩個人，在怎麼說動詞也應該用were...吧
4.選無可選情況下，只剩下B了

[Pudding]

老莫解法
1.一秒解題法，比較長短,B最短。b對

哈哈哈~!!! 實在是太傳神了....

[JS]

also consider parallelism.
A mixture of poems and short fiction, Jean Tommer's Cane .bla...bla...bla..........the others being Richard Wright's Native Son and Ralph Ellison's Invisible man.

So, I guess it should be E although initially I choose B


p.s. while I was in the loo(sorry) I cant resist to give this question a 2nd thought. I almost give up the answer E back to B , so I decided to look through CD and see if I can find some explainations. Here is what I find and I think it is pretty good... here it is

以下是引用lixunhuan在2005-1-22 1:08:00的发言：
这道题讨论了很久但始终没个结论.今天我请教的我的英语语法老师,a native English speaker and has been working as an English grammar teacher for 20+ years at one of the best public school districts in the U.S., 以下是她给我的结论:

The correct answer is E for the following reasons:

1. The novel, Cane by Jean Toomer, is the subject of the sentence. Therefore, in the second part of the sentence, which starts with "the others", the "others" should also be novels (not people).
2. Each book was written by a single individual, not by a group. Therefore, it should be "written by a Black American" rather than "by Black Americans".
3. In addition, answer E does a nice job of listing all three books in a consistent way. (i.e. "Jean Toomer's Cane". "Richard Wright's Native Son", Ralph Ellison's Invisible Man")

In conclusion, although initially I chose B, and then after few consideration I decided that E is better ,but while in the loo something tells me that B could be right, and finally, in order to settle my mind, I look through CD, all of a sudden everything seems clear that E is still the best, although I can not guarantee that this is 100% correct, but at least ..........oh my god, what am I doing.... why there are voices in my head........

[agk99]

選E比較好
這題我有實戰經驗
選完之後，下一題明顯變難
選B的朋友說，選完下一題都會明顯變簡單