[問題] From 22-Q17

[evelyn_yeh]

17. Cock's syndrome is a rare and incurable hereditary disorder that , [ like proge and Werner's synrome ] , is believed to accelerate and caricature the aging process .

(D) as proge and Werner's synrome are


ANS(A)
why not (D)

[envily]

我猜題目有誤喔
proge應該改為pro'geria n 早衰症 後面的synrome我認為要改為syndrome
所以 like比較兩邊等號 hereditary disorder like progeria's syndrome
that要擺到前面　以免修飾到 Warner's syndrome

[evelyn_yeh]

樓上同學,我不是問A有多麼正確(我不曾質疑A的正確性)
而是問 "why not D???"

[envily]

唔 別醬嘛 小咄咄逼人的說
答案藏在我在二樓寫的東西裡
OG中常強調
like 比較前後兩者名辭 as比較前後兩clause
所以我認為是disoder like progeria's syndrome
你問說為什麼不是 as Cock's syndrome are
那就是比較Cock's syndrome與 progeria's syndrome
此表達法redundent
大可直接寫Cock's syndrome, like progeria's syndrome 以緊鄰來修飾比較

[evelyn_yeh]

env大大,不好意思,因為我太急想知道答案...再過20天我就要考試啦,要命!!
如同您所說的,' as比較前後兩clause ',我的想法是
(1) Cock's syndrome is a rare and incurable disorder as proge and Cock's syndrome are .這樣就是前後兩clause 了,當然,如果要這樣表達,那 as~就不應放在that 的後面
(2) Cock's syndrome is a rare and incurable disorder that is believed to ~as proge and Cock's syndrome are (believed to ~)
這樣有什麼錯呢?? 請指教

[envily]

別降 其實我也只是考生 只是有點想法大家討論

第二個句子如果是that is believe, as progeria and Cock's syndrome are, to V
我覺得應該是沒問題
比較這個句子跟原題裡面的標準答案 我相信你應該能抓到comparison中的技巧摟