[討論]GWD7-1

[ivanchiang]

Although producer prices rose at an unexpectedly steep rate in September, analysts said that the increase resulted mostly from temporary factors and not necessarily foreshadowing that there would be a resurgence of inflation.

(A)factors and not necessarily foreshadowing that there would be
(B)factors and not necessarily that it foreshadowed
(C)factors and did not necessarily foreshadow
(D)factors, while not necessarily a foreshadowing of
(E)factors, while it did not necessarily foreshadow that there would be

Ans:C

想請問D、E

[lightblue]

我個人的選法是 foreshadow後面可以直接加受詞
所以E不選 因為簡潔 所以不用that子句
D因為a foreshadowing of 不選

另外 while感覺有改變句意的可能
不知回答的對不對 請多指教吧

[GoldDigger]

D、E留給其他高手仔細分析.

當初看這題時只覺得 and 或是 while 都有道理,
常常迷失在為什麼5個選擇的句意好像都有道理.
如果加上
平行: resulted..... did not necessarily foreshadow.......
跟隨原句句意: 用 and
或是一個不是每次對的判斷: 正確選項常在5個選項中佔三個.....
就可以直接選C而不會想太多了.

[autumn713]

來說一下我的想法好了 請大家指教
我ㄧ開始選E 因為覺得應該要有對立的語氣 所以一定要選DE 又D a foreshadowing of 太糟糕 所以選E...不過錯了 唉 還是第一題呢
後來想了想 因為foreshadow已經有預測的一絲 所以後面如果再出現類似假設語氣的用法 應該是redundancy 且預測就是一定會有 所以多了there would be更是多此一舉(道理應該同predict後面沒有occur一樣)
因此AE先刪 D又已經被刪了 所以剩BC.
B it多餘 所以剩C.