[問題]GWD21-7-9

[ergh]

Seventeenth-century
philosopher John Locke
stated that as much as
Line 99 percent of the value of
(5) any useful product can be
attributed to “the effects of
labor.” For Locke’s intellec-
tual heirs it was only a short
step to the “labor theory of
(10) value,” whose formulators
held that 100 percent of the
value of any product is gen-
erated by labor (the human
work needed to produce
(15) goods) and that therefore the
employer who appropriates
any part of the product’s
value as profit is practicing
theft.
(20) Although human effort is
required to produce goods
for the consumer market,
effort is also invested in
making capital goods (tools,
(25) machines, etc.), which are
used to facilitate the produc-
tion of consumer goods. In
modern economies about
one-third of the total output of
(30) consumer goods is attribut-
able to the use of capital
goods. Approximately two-
thirds of the income derived
from this total output is paid
(35) out to workers as wages and
salaries, the remaining third
serving as compensation
to the owners of the capital
goods. Moreover, part
(40) of this remaining third is
received by workers who
are shareholders, pension
beneficiaries, and the like.
The labor theory of value
(45) systematically disregards
the productive contribution of
capital goods-- a failing for
which Locke must bear part
of the blame.

GWD 21-7 C
According to the author of the passage, which of the following is true of the distribution of the income derived from the total output of consumer goods in a modern economy?
A.Workers receive a share of this income that is significantly smaller than the value of their labor as a contribution to total output.
B.Owners of capital goods receive a share of this income that is significantly greater than the contribution to total output attributable to the use of capital goods.
C.Owners of capital goods receive a share of this income that is no greater than the proportion of total output attributable to the use of capital goods.
D.Owners of capital goods are not fully compensated for their investment because they pay out most of their share of this income to workers as wages and benefits.
E.Workers receive a share of this income that is greater than the value of their labor because the labor theory of value overestimates their contribution to total output.

GWD 21-9 E
Which of the following arguments would a proponent of the labor theory of value, as it is presented in the first paragraph, be most likely to use in response to the statement that “The labor theory of value systematically disregards the productive contribution of capital goods” (lines 44-47)?
A.The productive contributions of workers and capital goods cannot be compared because the productive life span of capital goods is longer than that of workers.
B.The author’s analysis of the distribution of income is misleading because only a small percentage of workers are also shareholders.
C.Capital goods are valuable only insofar as they contribute directly to the production of consumer goods.
D.The productive contribution of capital goods must be discounted because capital goods require maintenance.
E.The productive contribution of capital goods must be attributed to labor because capital goods are themselves products of labor.

想請教一下第七題的答案為C的話，E為何不可？
第九題的答案為何為E?

[hcgh]

這裡已經有討論囉

[問題]GWD 21_Q7-Q9