[問題]GWD-6-21

[davidlee0222]

C選項裡有講"那些最有生產力的人"絕大多數工作十小時

[FionaV]

請問B選項
我的想法是...並不是上班的時數和天數讓他們變得很有工作效率 而是這群人本身就很productive
這樣的思路錯在哪裡?

[維尼]

請問B選項
我的想法是...並不是上班的時數和天數讓他們變得很有工作效率 而是這群人本身就很productive
這樣的思路錯在哪裡?

B選項並沒有你說的那個意思
他是說參與那個計劃的人不是自願的

[unwindedson]

C: 2 possibilities,
(1)如一天十小時，一週四天模式 "in the regional office"，
most productive workers have 2 hrs undisturbed
(2)working 10 hrs a day, allow most productive workers
have 2 hrs undisturbed(前提是加班情況)

D: provides another main incentive of efficiency per hour.
And hence weaken the boss's idea of switch mode to
evoke efficiency(=productivity, since 40 hr on both modes)

I think D is more proper, since the question doesn't provide any assumption about 加班

[pure822]

"D" is about the "payment system",but it does nothing to weaken that all employees work 10 hours, 4 days can increase productivity.It simply says the pay is based on how productive they are. It doesn't "explain" if company change the working hours to 10 hours a day,the productivity will not be increased.Therefore, it can't weaken the president's plan.

[Austing]

"D" is about the "payment system",but it does nothing to weaken that all employees work 10 hours, 4 days can increase productivity.It simply says the pay is based on how productive they are. It doesn't "explain" if company change the working hours to 10 hours a day,the productivity will not be increased.Therefore, it can't weaken the president's plan.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
president’s plan-->8 hrs a day , 5 dys a week to 10 hrs a day, 4 dys a week
stated purpose-->more productive

Weaken!
E.Those SaleCo employees who have a four-day workweek do not take any of their office work to do at home on Friday.不會把工作偷偷帶回家作.....'cos it's out of scope?? or ???
somebody gives me a favor plz!

[dibert8]

(A) 做四天,少一個下午=> support
(B) 自願不自願沒什麼關係吧!老總改工時不也是非自願?
(C) 前人工作10小時,多出兩小時沒有人干擾,現在大家都工作10小時,就會互相干擾,削弱生產力.
(D) 中性: 不支持但弱化不及(C). 現行誘因已經是以生產力計算加給.也許生產力好是因為獎金制度,而不是每日工時.無法解釋為何只有工作10hr的人生產力好,跟獎金有什麼關係.
(E) 工作帶不帶回家做,好像沒什麼關聯吧!

[jinoliway]

我也不了解為什麼E不能？
if E is true=> 那些一週工作四天的人其實週五在家也在工作=>效率事實上沒有提高=>可反駁老闆的改革計畫

當然我也認為C是的非常好的答案，只是E也是我的考慮選項。他真的離題了嘛？