[問題]真題一道

[fannie_du]

Newspaper reviews of film adaptations of well-known books or plays frequently concentrate on the adaptation's fidelity. Granted, many people go to such films wanting to see a version of the original. However, reviewers do a poor job by taking this approach, since faithfulness to the original is irrelenvant to the film's own artistic merit.

Which of the following, if true, most seriously weakens the argument？

A The central purpose of newspaper reviews of films is to enable readers to find out whether they would enjoy seeing the film.

B. Often the attempt to capitlize on a well-known novel's fame by making a film version backfires, since a long novel's narrative must to overly compressed to fit a film.

C. A film's artistic merit does not depend on the film's relationship to other works of art.

D. Newspaper reviws of films that are not adaptations of well-known books or plays tend to concentrate on issues relevant to the film's artistic merit.

E. Film producers expect adaptations of well-known originals to be more financially successful than other films.


Answer：A


我的理解是：報紙影評在評論改編著名書的電影時，經常著重在是否忠於原著，許多人看這類電影時希望看到原著，然而，因為忠於原著與電影本身的藝術是無相關的，所以影評是失職的。
看完實在是不太懂題目要反駁哪裡？是影評是失職那句嗎？

[A級垂耳兔]

你的題目是從哪裡來的??
是PP上面的嗎?還是考古題?

[fannie_du]

你的題目是從哪裡來的??
是PP上面的嗎?還是考古題?

是上 來欣謝老師的11張講義
我看了一下發文規則
無法歸類的是用這標題
要是標錯 麻煩請告知我 真的很抱歉 第一次發文 請見諒

[A級垂耳兔]

哈..我不是版主..別緊張…
我會這麼問只是我不想碰考古題…補習班那些老掉牙不求進步的傢伙你在給他50年去教….還是在弄考古題…考古題對現在考試ㄧ點幫助都沒有….
如果是PP題目就會讓人有想回答的衝動….
小弟我就是把考古題都做完的那種笨蛋….浪費寶貴時間…沒辦法..誰叫我沒種自己唸…要跑去補習班被人家誤導…..不好意思..說太多了…如果是考古題建議你丟到旁邊…多唸唸OG反而比較有用..因為有解釋….

[eddybasic]

Newspaper reviews of film adaptations of well-known books or plays frequently concentrate on the adaptation's fidelity. Granted, many people go to such films wanting to see a version of the original. However, reviewers do a poor job by taking this approach, since faithfulness to the original is irrelenvant to the film's own artistic merit.

Which of the following, if true, most seriously weakens the argument？

A The central purpose of newspaper reviews of films is to enable readers to find out whether they would enjoy seeing the film.

B. Often the attempt to capitlize on a well-known novel's fame by making a film version backfires, since a long novel's narrative must to overly compressed to fit a film.

C. A film's artistic merit does not depend on the film's relationship to other works of art.

D. Newspaper reviws of films that are not adaptations of well-known books or plays tend to concentrate on issues relevant to the film's artistic merit.

E. Film producers expect adaptations of well-known originals to be more financially successful than other films.


Answer：A


我的理解是：報紙影評在評論改編著名書的電影時，經常著重在是否忠於原著，許多人看這類電影時希望看到原著，然而，因為忠於原著與電影本身的藝術是無相關的，所以影評是失職的。
看完實在是不太懂題目要反駁哪裡？是影評是失職那句嗎？

個人認為是的
作邏輯把握兩個要點,第一,因果找出來
第二,結論句找出來
影評失職的那一句就是結論句
他說影評失職(結論),因為忠於原著跟美感沒有關係(因果)
反駁是說影評沒有失職,因為影評的目的是要讓觀眾知道是否他們喜歡這部電影,而有沒有美感並不是影評要考慮的重點

open to discuss~