[問題] 考古題 CR Form18 sec3 Q2

[ariesmichael]

各位大大... 小弟正開始上GMAT的課...
這一題, 似乎有點了解, 又有點模糊... 那位高手可否伸出援手協助...
剛才爬文了一下... 好像沒有人詢問過... 可能這對大家來說都太簡單了... ^^

2. The chief executive officer of one of the country's most successful steel manufacturing firms is amused at the publicity her management practices have attracted. She thinks managers get too much of the credit for upswings in their businesses. "A fickle public assumes too easily that managers are brilliant when demand is strong and idiotic when it is weak." she assets.

It can be inferred from the statement made by the chief executive officer that she believes which of the following?

(A) A successful manager should attempt to control public opinion.
(B) There are no managers who can justifiably be said to be brilliant.
(C) Her own management practices are likely to be of little value to other business.
(D) The role of managers becomes less important during economic downturns than it is in relatively prosperous times.
(E) The level of demand for the products of manufacturing firms cannot be completely controlled by the managers of the firms.



ANSWER ---> (E)

[Frankts]

可以請問一下 題目有些字有打錯嗎 還有問題是什麼?
不過我看了一下題目 接著試著去看答案
我居然選對了 題目是問假設還是支持嗎?

[ariesmichael]

Dear Frankts:

謝謝您的細心... 原本的確有打錯字, 也忘了寫出問題...
不過, 現在已經修正並且補上... 還要請您多多指教!

可以請問一下 題目有些字有打錯嗎 還有問題是什麼?
不過我看了一下題目 接著試著去看答案
我居然選對了 題目是問假設還是支持嗎?

[Frankts]

我的思考不一定對 不過我說說看我的想法 給你做參考
題目問 文章中隱含些什麼 基本上就是去看題目
然後 換句話說 (不要加入自己的想法)
"A fickle public assumes too easily that managers are brilliant when demand is strong and idiotic when it is weak." she assets.
這句話 我覺得E的選項最符合 其他的都有加入一些沒有提到的東西
希望這樣能有幫助 或者你對哪個選項比較有疑問
可以說說自己的想法 這樣大家比較好幫忙

[ariesmichael]

其實這一題給我的感覺就是似懂非懂的...
因為現在才剛開始做題目... 所以希望可以完全地了解問題...
更何況... 這一題, 我ㄧ開始做錯了...

以下為我針對statement以及每個選項的看法, 我希望可以了解你們的想法, 這樣我可以修正並像你們學習...

"A fickle public assumes too easily that managers are brilliant when demand is strong and idiotic when it is weak." she assets.
CEO這句話的涵義是她認為大眾以需求的強弱來判斷一個管理者好壞是不公平的.

(A) A successful manager should attempt to control public opinion.
statement未提

(B) There are no managers who can justifiably be said to be brilliant.
錯誤, 違背CEO的想法

(C) Her own management practices are likely to be of little value to other business.
statement未提

(D) The role of managers becomes less important during economic downturns than it is in relatively prosperous times.
錯誤, 違背CEO的想法

(E) The level of demand for the products of manufacturing firms cannot be completely controlled by the managers of the firms.
產品製造公司的管理者根本無法控制需求的強弱

我的思考不一定對 不過我說說看我的想法 給你做參考
題目問 文章中隱含些什麼 基本上就是去看題目
然後 換句話說 (不要加入自己的想法)
"A fickle public assumes too easily that managers are brilliant when demand is strong and idiotic when it is weak." she assets.
這句話 我覺得E的選項最符合 其他的都有加入一些沒有提到的東西
希望這樣能有幫助 或者你對哪個選項比較有疑問
可以說說自己的想法 這樣大家比較好幫忙

[dibert8]

這題問 assumption
結論是: managers get too much of the credit for upswings in their businesses 經理人在多頭時功過其實
(E) 取非: 經理人可以控管需求; 如此, 經理人就實至名歸了. 因此否定了結論. 就這樣確認答案.

[Frankts]

結論是這個喔 : managers get too much of the credit for upswings in their businesses
我以為是下面那一句 那看來我的思考方向應該也不是很對
希望沒有誤導到ariesmichael

[ariesmichael]

這題問 assumption
結論是: managers get too much of the credit for upswings in their businesses 經理人在多頭時功過其實
(E) 取非: 經理人可以控管需求; 如此, 經理人就實至名歸了. 因此否定了結論. 就這樣確認答案.

Dear dibert8

謝謝您的分享, 我想或許還要多多練功(做做題目並檢討), 才能夠達到您一眼就洞悉出關鍵的能力...
以下我還有幾個問題想要請教:
1. 對於其他錯誤選項, 您是否有希望補充或提供寶貴意見的呢?
2. 根據你的回覆, 請問, 當我們選擇答案(E)之後, 最好利用「取非」的方式來反證, 以更確認選答的正確性...: 以這一題為例, CEO認為經理人多頭時供過其實,因此選項(E)若改為 "否定", 則與statement相違背; 反之, 則確認答案.

P.S. 上述問題2如果與您的意思一致, 請不要介意, 因為這樣double check可以協助我思考... 也再次謝謝您的耐心

結論是這個喔 不要告訴別人 : managers get too much of the credit for upswings in their businesses
我以為是下面那一句 那看來我的思考方向應該也不是很對
希望沒有誤導到ariesmichael

Dear Frankts:

不用擔心誤導啦... 討論區就是大家一起討論並加上自己的意見...
你昨天要我說明我的想法, 老實說, 我也是怕怕的
我到希望鼓勵大家不論是否100%確定, 都可以跟大家分享...
因為反覆的思考過程中, 我也是在學習阿!!!

anyway, 還是謝謝您囉!

Michael