[問題]OG 62

[atrada]

62.Geologists believe that the warning signs for a major earthquake
may include sudden fluctuations in local seismic activity,tilting and
other deformations of the Earth's crust, changing the measured
strain across a fault zone, and varying the eletrical properties of
underground rocks.
(E)changes in measurements of the strain across a fault zone, and variations among

請問一下喔...OG上對AMONG的解釋是說
among in E wrongly suggests a comparison of different electrical properties rather than of different behaviors of the same properties
請問一下是什麼意思阿
這是跟用in的差別嗎?如果是降...請哪為好心的大大可以幫我解釋一下用這兩者的差別

[micht]

62.Geologists believe that the warning signs for a major earthquake
may include sudden fluctuations in local seismic activity,tilting and
other deformations of the Earth's crust, changing the measured
strain across a fault zone, and varying the eletrical properties of
underground rocks.

(D)changes in the measured strain across a fault zone, and varioations in
(E)changes in measurements of the strain across a fault zone, and variations among

Ans: (D)

variations in the electrical properties [之內]
variations among the electrical properties [之間]

among in E wrongly suggests a comparison of different electrical properties rather than of different behaviors of the same properties

嗯 OG 其實解釋ㄉ蠻清楚的說...

[agk99]

下次請貼完整，這樣才能方便上班也想偷偷K書的朋友
我記得好像不是選E，選幾我也忘了，但看解釋，知道選E會改變句意
among，講的是comparison of different properties, in，講的是different behavior
最近大家習慣查字典，所以我也貼上長人字典的解釋
variation in(感覺較精確)
variations in the quality of the rugs

variation among(感覺是一個概括的東西)
There is a great deal of variation among the responses.

[atrada]

下次請貼完整，這樣才能方便上班也想偷偷K書的朋友
我記得好像不是選E，選幾我也忘了，但看解釋，知道選E會改變句意
among，講的是comparison of different properties, in，講的是different behavior
最近大家習慣查字典，所以我也貼上長人字典的解釋
variation in(感覺較精確)
variations in the quality of the rugs

variation among(感覺是一個概括的東西)
There is a great deal of variation among the responses.

下次會改進的><第一次po不好意思.....
嗯我想我懂了...那還是要看整劇的意思再來決定要用among或是in就是了

[liwuu]

嗯...從整句的意思是指地底石頭的electrical properties變動狀況,若是用among就變成是指不同electrical properties之間的變動

[pcl12]

想請問一下，這句的平衡是哪幾個名詞的平衡？
我覺得是fluctuations. changes. variations
可是og的解釋不是這樣...我弄錯哪裡了嗎?

[agk99]

我想你理解應該沒什麼錯

D, the best choice, describes the warning signs in parallel phrases. Despite surface appearances, the nouns changes and variations are parallel with tilting, but the verbal forms changing and varying in A, B, and C are not: tilting, one of the deformations of the Earth’s crust, is used here as a noun that is parallel to fluctuations, whereas changing and varying are used as verbs indicating some action undertaken. Moreover, these verbs are used incorrectly because the sentence mentions no subject that is performing these actions. B and E illogically state that it is not the strain but the measurements that portend danger, and among in E wrongly suggests a comparison of different electrical properties rather than of different behaviors of the same properties.

[pcl12]

我想你理解應該沒什麼錯

D, the best choice, describes the warning signs in parallel phrases. Despite surface appearances, the nouns changes and variations are parallel with tilting, but the verbal forms changing and varying in A, B, and C are not: tilting, one of the deformations of the Earth’s crust, is used here as a noun that is parallel to fluctuations, whereas changing and varying are used as verbs indicating some action undertaken. Moreover, these verbs are used incorrectly because the sentence mentions no subject that is performing these actions. B and E illogically state that it is not the strain but the measurements that portend danger, and among in E wrongly suggests a comparison of different electrical properties rather than of different behaviors of the same properties.

不好意思,藍色字的部份看得不很懂

[soami]

我想你理解應該沒什麼錯

D, the best choice, describes the warning signs in parallel phrases. Despite surface appearances, the nouns changes and variations are parallel with tilting, but the verbal forms changing and varying in A, B, and C are not: tilting, one of the deformations of the Earth’s crust, is used here as a noun that is parallel to fluctuations, whereas changing and varying are used as verbs indicating some action undertaken. Moreover, these verbs are used incorrectly because the sentence mentions no subject that is performing these actions. B and E illogically state that it is not the strain but the measurements that portend danger, and among in E wrongly suggests a comparison of different electrical properties rather than of different behaviors of the same properties.

不好意思,藍色字的部份看得不很懂

藍色部分是說使用changes and variations這二個名詞和tiltling平行，但是
動名詞changing varing則不平行，changing varing可以當名詞用，但是這二
個名詞具有正在進行的意味，不適合題意要的是一種地理現象，所以用changes and variations better。

結論是ets用titling來騙人，重點在句意的判斷上。

[pcl12]

藍色部分是說使用changes and variations這二個名詞和tiltling平行，但是
動名詞changing varing則不平行，changing varing可以當名詞用，但是這二
個名詞具有正在進行的意味，不適合題意要的是一種地理現象，所以用changes and variations better。

結論是ets用titling來騙人，重點在句意的判斷上。

changes and variations和tilting平行?我實在看不出來..
tilting 是動名詞吧..
反而還覺得changing and varing 和tilting較平行...都是V-ing..
嗯嗯,如果說有進行的意味的話,當然和地理現象就蠻不同的..
我看的時候覺得,因為fluctuationa. changes. variations
這3字都有改變的意味,所以這3個平衡蠻有道理的,而tilting我把他視為插入,修飾
seismic activity

[soami]

changes and variations和tilting平行?我實在看不出來..
tilting 是動名詞吧..
反而還覺得changing and varing 和tilting較平行...都是V-ing..
嗯嗯,如果說有進行的意味的話,當然和地理現象就蠻不同的..
我看的時候覺得,因為fluctuationa. changes. variations
這3字都有改變的意味,所以這3個平衡蠻有道理的,而tilting我把他視為插入,修飾
seismic activity[/quote]

首先tilting是動名詞沒錯，不過查了字典tilt也可以當作名詞用，這裡使用
動名詞的原因我不太清楚。

如果如你所說titling，changing 和 varying平行的話，我們來分析句型
1.tilting and other deformations of the Earth's crust
2.changing the measured strain across a fault zone
3.varying the electrical properties of underground rocks
2.3句動名詞後面接受詞補語，但是第一句titling是用介係詞補語

再看ets給的正確選項 fluctuations in, tilting and deformations of, changes in,
variations in 看起來這個比較平衡。

ets的解釋還說了一點為什麼用changing varing不好，因為使用動名詞最好
有一個明確的主詞來做這些動作。

至於為什麼tilt要用動名詞我真的不知道，有沒有其他人可以指點一下。

[魚]

至於為什麼tilt要用動名詞我真的不知道，有沒有其他人可以指點一下。

hi :soami

tilt :The tilt of something is the fact that it tilts or slopes, or the angle at which it tilts or slopes.

我大膽去信中研院請教了相關領域的學者,他們的回信中也同意,在他們的學術領域中習慣採用 tile 的名詞型來表示 the angle at which it tilts or slopes. 這樣的用法與文章中所要表達的句意不符,這或許也是採用V-ing的原因吧

僅供參考.

[soami]

至於為什麼tilt要用動名詞我真的不知道，有沒有其他人可以指點一下。

hi :soami

tilt :The tilt of something is the fact that it tilts or slopes, or the angle at which it tilts or slopes.

我大膽去信中研院請教了相關領域的學者,他們的回信中也同意,在他們的學術領域中習慣採用 tile 的名詞型來表示 the angle at which it tilts or slopes. 這樣的用法與文章中所要表達的句意不符,這或許也是採用V-ing的原因吧

僅供參考.

hihi魚，好感動你還特地寫信去請教。
順便請教一下我的說法有沒有錯誤，這題畫線部份直接用名詞平衡比較好。

[Behemoth]

動名詞 是 名詞 的一種啊
本題是用名詞平衡解題沒錯

[davidlee0222]

同意B大跟魚大