[問題]GWD21-41

[cimim]

GWD 21-41
The Environmental Protection Agency’s proposal to place restrictions on both diesel fuel and diesel engines has sparked a counterattack by the oil industry, saying that the move will exacerbate the nation’s fuel supply problems.

A.on both diesel fuel and diesel engines has sparked a counterattack by the oil industry, saying
B.on both diesel fuel and engines have sparked the oil industry to counterattack, and they say
C.on both diesel fuel and diesel engines has sparked a counterattack by the oil industry, which says
D.both on diesel fuel and engines has sparked the oil industry to a counterattack, saying
E.both on diesel fuel and diesel engines have sparked the oil industry to counterattack, and it says


both and 平衡 刪掉BDE)
剩下AC 決選 我以為片語比子句要來的好 選了A
可是答案是C)

[林小馬]

both and 平衡 刪掉BDE)
剩下AC 決選 我以為片語比子句要來的好 選了A
可是答案是C)

我在想啊
A的話saying會變成在講proposal
可是say的主辭應該是counterattack

[antlai]

可是這樣的話，答案C裡面的which不就變成代替 industry了??
是我搞錯了嗎?

[林小馬]

可是這樣的話，答案C裡面的which不就變成代替 industry了??
是我搞錯了嗎?

OH~~
對不起 那says的主詞是industry
謝謝指點啊~~~

恩
應該說現在有正反兩面,
正面是Agency's proposal to place restriction
反面是the counterattack by the oil industry
從句意來看say後面的內容是跟著反面觀點的
所以跟著正面觀點的就通通錯

[stilalala]

可是這樣的話，答案C裡面的which不就變成代替 industry了??
是我搞錯了嗎?

OH~~
對不起 那says的主詞是industry
謝謝指點啊~~~

恩
應該說現在有正反兩面,
正面是Agency's proposal to place restriction
反面是the counterattack by the oil industry
從句意來看say後面的內容是跟著反面觀點的
所以跟著正面觀點的就通通錯

呵呵不小心回錯篇了
抱歉
別理這篇

[Kyo]

可是這樣的話，答案C裡面的which不就變成代替 industry了??
是我搞錯了嗎?

主詞是oil industry沒錯啊
oil industry說這樣的限制會導致燃料供應惡化啊，所以他們要counterattack這個限制，句意上相當合理唷。

[auguding]

頂一下
那為何不能選A呢
不跟C一樣都是說INDUSTRY嘛
那A不是比起C的關代好嗎??
TKS啊!!!!

[hcgh]

C比較好
which就是指代其前的名詞

A的saying，有下列幾種可能，會產生歧義
1. saying形容proposal
2. saying形容前面一整句
3. saying形容industry