[討論]大全966

[swiss0204]

966. In repousse, a method of sculpture, workers lay copper sheets over wooden molds, and then, using a variety of exotic hammers, carefully pounding the metal into shape.

(A) In repousse, a method of sculpture, workers lay copper sheets over wooden molds, and then, using a variety of exotic hammers, carefully pounding the metal into shape.
(B) Repousse is method of sculpture in which workers lay copper sheets over wooden molds and then, using a variety of exotic hammers, carefully pound the metal into shape.
(C) Repousse workers, who do a method of sculpture by laying copper sheets over wooden molds, use a variety of exotic hammers, and then pounding the metal into shape.
(D) Workers who lay copper sheets over wooden molds use a variety of exotic hammers and carefully pound the metal into shape in order to do repousse, a method of sculpture.
(E) Laying copper sheets over wooden molds, and using a variety of exotic hammers in order to pound the metal into shape, repousse is a method of sculpture done by workers.　

Answer : B.

以下有幾個疑惑, 請NN 們代為幫忙解答一下~
1) 我選choice D, 很疑惑choice D 錯在哪部分?
此外, 在 choice D 裡, 句尾的a method of sculpture 是repousse 的同位語. 此部分有任何
dangling modification 嗎?
2) choice B 裡, using a variety of exotic hammers 放在句中的伴隨用法,不是會造成 修飾歧義, 而容易造成是修飾Repousse 而非 workers ?

Thanks ~ !!

[achiachia]

考古題FORM24 ＃25

莫老師說：
D）的主題錯誤，題目的主題是 "Repousse is......."
而C）,D） and E）的主題是 "workers do...." 意思有偏差。

而"using a variety of exotic hammers" 修飾動詞pound

[souljuice]

我想第二個問題 ，現在分詞放在句中的修飾歧異問題，基本上在這個句中是沒有的，句中的現在分詞修飾會有歧義主要都是在前後都緊接著名詞的時候，會不知道要修飾前面的還是後面的名詞，這一題中，沒有這樣的歧異問題，很明顯的，是一個伴隨動作。 有說錯請見諒

[hsudk]

句中的現在分詞修飾會有歧義主要都是在前後都緊接著名詞的時候，會不知道要修飾前面的還是後面的名詞，

現在分詞修飾的用法：
1.現在分詞若前面有逗號時，則修飾主詞
2.現在分詞前面沒有逗號時，則修飾緊緊跟在它前面的名詞
此題B選項中using...當插入語，優先修飾which這個clause的主語:workers.

[keane0727]

就因為此分詞片語的位置是插入句中所以不會形成two-way modifier or dangling modifier

workers V1 (lay).... and　then, using....., V2 (pound) .

我們較熟悉的分詞位罝是 S1..V1, V2ing，但若些題Ans B將分詞片語放在句尾的話就真得形成dangling modifier了
workers lay....and then carefully pound the metal into shape, using a variety of exotic hammers. (using因為緊跟在shape後所以讓人覺得是在修飾shape)

[keane0727]

D文法皆正確，同位語用的很精準
D錯的原因是因為句意爛得一蹋糊塗

[dibert8]

(D) to do repousse 應該是 to make repousse