天山7-Q31

[best555tw]

Q31:
At an orientation meeting, the travelers were told that a visa, a landing card, and evidence of inoculation against typhoid fever would be needed by each of them.
A. a visa, a landing card, and evidence of inoculation against typhoid fever would be needed by each of them
B. they would need a visa, a landing card, and evidence of their being inoculated against typhoid fever
C. they would need evidence of being inoculated against typhoid fever and a visa and landing card
D. they would each need a visa, a landing card, and evidence of inoculation against typhoid fever
E. they would need visas, landing cards, and evidence of inoculation against typhoid fever for each of them

找不到這題的討論
好像沒討論過吧

答案D
我選A
they would each??????
為什麼會是D呢?

[Pufa]

其實A的意思跟D一樣阿。
A: a visa would be needed by each of them.
D: they would each have a visa.
只不過是主被動的差別而已哩~

我記得OG裡也有『複數名詞』+each的用法。

[CUGGYER]

E. they would need visas, landing cards, and evidence of inoculation against typhoid fever for each of them

請問E 的 for each of them 有什麼不好嗎?

他是錯在哪裡呢

[Pufa]

E. they would need visas, landing cards, and evidence of inoculation against typhoid fever for each of them

請問E 的 for each of them 有什麼不好嗎?

他是錯在哪裡呢

them指誰不確定。
有可能是visas、cards。

[SugarChunda]

E選項的each of them是不是應該用themselves呢 ?? 因為主詞與受詞一致時, 應該用反身代名詞.... 小小意見, 歡迎指教 !!

[Shane]

Q31:
At an orientation meeting, the travelers were told that a visa, a landing card, and evidence of inoculation against typhoid fever would be needed by each of them.
A. a visa, a landing card, and evidence of inoculation against typhoid fever would be needed by each of them
B. they would need a visa, a landing card, and evidence of their being inoculated against typhoid fever
C. they would need evidence of being inoculated against typhoid fever and a visa and landing card
D. they would each need a visa, a landing card, and evidence of inoculation against typhoid fever
E. they would need visas, landing cards, and evidence of inoculation against typhoid fever for each of them

找不到這題的討論
好像沒討論過吧

答案D
我選A
they would each??????
為什麼會是D呢?

個人愚見。
當時A與D猶豫，後來選了A，當下覺得如果A不是答案，理由應為：
第一，redundance：....by each of them是多餘的（而且them也有混淆視聽之虞）
第二，被動。主動和被動來看，主動勝被動一籌，畢竟subject是the travels。

[jameslu1208]

Q31:
At an orientation meeting, the travelers were told that a visa, a landing card, and evidence of inoculation against typhoid fever would be needed by each of them.
A. a visa, a landing card, and evidence of inoculation against typhoid fever would be needed by each of them
B. they would need a visa, a landing card, and evidence of their being inoculated against typhoid fever
C. they would need evidence of being inoculated against typhoid fever and a visa and landing card
D. they would each need a visa, a landing card, and evidence of inoculation against typhoid fever
E. they would need visas, landing cards, and evidence of inoculation against typhoid fever for each of them

找不到這題的討論
好像沒討論過吧

答案D
我選A
they would each??????
為什麼會是D呢?

這題再稍微講一下我覺得可能大家會誤解的地方 高手們就跳過吧！
(A)、(D) 的each 在這邊的詞性並不一樣
A是代名詞 D 的each則是副詞修飾need
所以如果有人覺得D的each後面為啥還接複數動詞
原因在這邊 Each在此不當作名詞 純粹只是當副詞

[jinoliway]

原來是當副詞
懂了 完全瞭解

[lucyyeh]

雖然我覺得單數受詞的選項E看起來也很順眼，
可是這一題竟然跑出複數受詞的選項了
E. they would need visas, landing cards, and evidence of inoculation against typhoid fever for each of them.
我覺得這樣也很合理阿，因為travelers是複數，所以應該就不只一張visa, or landing card，剛好evidence是不可數，所以受詞也一致了。
請問這樣的句型到底該用單數還是複數才對呢?

[dibert8]

(E) 的句意不合理: 'for each of them' 每個人只需要一個 visa 就行啦!