GWD4-Q4

[QQcandy]

Q4:
A new hair-growing drug is being sold for three times the price, per milligram, as the drug’s maker charges for another product with the same active ingredient.

A. as
B. than
C. that
D. of what
E. at which

The correct answer is C or D ? Anyone can explain ?

[agk99]

我很痛苦，選了C
請公布答案

[Moloch]

我想答案應該是d

(H)

[illuna]

我做的時候選A :-$

不過現在看一看應該是D

考點是不是在 three times the price of+what名詞子句

記得老莫在解考古題P.100 Q27題時有講過類似的考點....

N1(=price)of N2(=what名詞子句....)

名詞子句可以當price的同位.....思考中華民國結構....the Republic of China

還記得老莫說句意就是看到theory就會問what theory....

所以本題看到price就要問what price....I guess

Moloch該不會是老莫吧???功力那麼強.... :D

那就讓我越俎代庖一下...先幫Mo同學解釋一點點...賺點咖啡豆... 8-|

[Moloch]

的確...
正如illuna大大所說...
這邊用中華民國結構來解十分清楚~~~

我稍微補充一點點囉...
這邊正確答案中的of what 其實可以還原成 of the price that
因為前面price講過了...
所以直接用what代較簡潔 :D

對了...我只是一個無名小卒啦... :P
跟大家一起切磋好的想法...一起進步囉...

[魚]

拍謝啦 ~

小M , 我覺得你的解釋狠不錯 ,不過

偶考慮了一下 還是 想選 A 耶....

我覺得 , as 就是準關代的用法啊 , 狠漂亮啊 ^^

而且我記得(不大確定 ) what 沒有接在介係詞後面耶.....

所以才會有比較爛的文法書上直接寫 what=in which 啊

(禮貌一下) 請指正 ~

[QQcandy]

拍謝啦 ~

小M , 我覺得你的解釋狠不錯 ,不過

偶考慮了一下 還是 想選 A 耶....

我覺得 , as 就是準關代的用法啊 , 狠漂亮啊 ^^

而且我記得(不大確定 ) what 沒有接在介係詞後面耶.....

所以才會有比較爛的文法書上直接寫 what=in which 啊

(禮貌一下) 請指正 ~

魚MM

我查了一下莫北北的單張講義, 他也有談到 as 當關代的問題ㄛ...

但是他講的是 as....as...的用法, 第一個 as 是副詞, 第二個才是關代...

ex. As many children as came here were my father's students. (as = who)
ex. You shall have as much money as you need. (as =which)

不知在此題可以這樣用嗎 ?? 因為只有一個 as

[魚]

拍謝啦 ~

小M , 我覺得你的解釋狠不錯 ,不過

偶考慮了一下 還是 想選 A 耶....

我覺得 , as 就是準關代的用法啊 , 狠漂亮啊 ^^

而且我記得(不大確定 ) what 沒有接在介係詞後面耶.....

所以才會有比較爛的文法書上直接寫 what=in which 啊

(禮貌一下) 請指正 ~

魚MM

我查了一下莫北北的單張講義, 他也有談到 as 當關代的問題ㄛ...

但是他講的是 as....as...的用法, 第一個 as 是副詞, 第二個才是關代...

ex. As many children as came here were my father's students. (as = who)
ex. You shall have as much money as you need. (as =which)

不知在此題可以這樣用嗎 ?? 因為只有一個 as

嗯 QQ糖JJ 挖也是有這個疑慮 ,不過 準關代的意義不是固定搭配
所以我也有點煩惱

橘子大哥 你去問一下莫北北好嗎 ^^ :D

[Moloch]

拍謝啦 ~

小M , 我覺得你的解釋狠不錯 ,不過

我覺得 , as 就是準關代的用法啊 , 狠漂亮啊 ^^

而且我記得(不大確定 ) what 沒有接在介係詞後面耶.....

所以才會有比較爛的文法書上直接寫 what=in which 啊

(禮貌一下) 請指正 ~

魚MM

我查了一下莫北北的單張講義, 他也有談到 as 當關代的問題ㄛ...

但是他講的是 as....as...的用法, 第一個 as 是副詞, 第二個才是關代...

ex. As many children as came here were my father's students. (as = who)
ex. You shall have as much money as you need. (as =which)

不知在此題可以這樣用嗎 ?? 因為只有一個 as

首先....的確如qq所說...
要有as...as...結構時才會產生準關代的用法...

再者...
的確有介係詞加what的用法....
找個例句好了..
the average worker decreased the amount or value of what could be bought.

[agk99]

我稍微補充一點點囉...
這邊正確答案中的of what 其實可以還原成 of the price that
因為前面price講過了...
所以直接用what代較簡潔 :D

我正在想of是怎麼來的，看到你的說法，雖然不知這是不是考點，但我覺得你這樣解這是好樣的

那補充再問一個，per milligram是不是插入句呀，是的話我就忽略了喔

[魚]

:P

不要打我 !!!! 作題多不如作題精

GGJJDDMM

魚又有新發現了 嘿嘿

E ) at which <---這個答案如何 ?? 不賴唄

new hair-growing drug is being sold for three times the price at which the drug’s maker charges for another product with the same active ingredient.
(Y) (Y) (Y) 越看越滿意

大家來討論吧

今天發現我很堅貞....來改簽名擋吧

[Behemoth]

:P

不要打我 !!!! 作題多不如作題精

GGJJDDMM

魚又有新發現了 嘿嘿

E ) at which <---這個答案如何 ?? 不賴唄

new hair-growing drug is being sold for three times the price at which the drug’s maker charges for another product with the same active ingredient.
(Y) (Y) (Y) 越看越滿意

大家來討論吧

今天發現我很堅貞....來改簽名擋吧

魚妹妹...
如果照你所說選e的話....那which要代誰呢???
這裡並沒有先行詞給which代啊...
這邊在劃線部分後面缺少一個主詞...而e選項並不能符合要主詞的要求
而which本身並不能做為主詞
翻成中文看會不會好一點...
這種新藥的價錢是藥商對另外一種有相同主要成分之藥要價的三倍價錢
注意這邊是價錢跟價錢在比...


另外....原句還原的話...應該是所謂介係詞孤兒的形式...
new hair-growing drug is being sold for three times the price at which the drug’s maker charges for another product with the same active ingredient
變成
the drug’s maker charges for another product with the same active ingredient at the price
那這樣一來的話price的介係詞用at...不是有點怪嗎...
一般來說應該用for吧...

[Jessy]

其實我還是想選C耶
charge sb/st. for st.
用關代that代替the price作為後面the drug’s maker charges 的受詞..
唉呀! 我這樣想到底哪邊出問題啊??

[Jessy]

頂一下, 誰可以告訴我到底哪邊有問題阿??

[魚]

jessy , 現在的我也比較偏向於選C

覺得當初太鑽了


醬好了 , 我們呼叫莫北北代表 ,請他去跟莫北北確認吧 ^^

還有 , 不要喪氣喔 !

這不是考誰的英文好 ,是考誰的氣長~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~