[問題]考古題form32 #20 (p.79)

[colorr]

In December of 1987 an automobile manufacturer pleaded
no contest to criminal charges of odometer tampering and
agreed to pay more than $16 million in civil damages for
cars that were test-driven with their odometers disconnected.

(A) cars that were test-driven with their odometers disconnected
(B) cars that it had test-driven with disconnected odometers
(C) its cars having been test-driven with disconnected odometers
(D) having test-driven cars with their odometers disconnected
(E) having cars that were test-driven with disconnected odometers

答案是D，但我還是不懂
麻煩各位為我解惑，我選A
謝謝[/url]

[bugubugu]

In December of 1987 an automobile manufacturer pleaded
no contest to criminal charges of odometer tampering and
agreed to pay more than $16 million in civil damages for
cars that were test-driven with their odometers disconnected.

(A) cars that were test-driven with their odometers disconnected
(B) cars that it had test-driven with disconnected odometers
(C) its cars having been test-driven with disconnected odometers
(D) having test-driven cars with their odometers disconnected
(E) having cars that were test-driven with disconnected odometers

答案是D，但我還是不懂
麻煩各位為我解惑，我選A
謝謝[/url]

這題看不懂題意就不可能對....
是考修釋語誤置...
因為哩程表odometers必須修釋名詞car...
其他的都是修釋test-driven ...
因為沒人用哩程表試車句意怪...
所以只有D能選...

[Ethan]

給Bugubugu拍拍手!
講的很好! (Y) (Y) (Y)

[gaspper]

但是我覺得 having test-driven car 更怪。having 在這裡看起來像是 had test-driven 分詞變形而來。如果是這樣的話，那時間發生在前的根本不能變成分詞。不知道我有沒有誤解。

[yhlin]

這題我也覺得很怪，
其實嚴格說起來應該5個答案都不對，沒有一個是正確的...

[A級垂耳兔]

樓上的想太多了...不要看到having就先砍掉...這樣很吃虧的...having做正確答案在GWD裡面也是有的....要砍的是having been這種東西(管衛東講義裡面有)....
答案D的having是使役動詞...主動形式在介詞後面當然用ing
本題結構是have+O+O.C