[問題]OG 179

[pcl12]

179.
A museum has been offered an undocumented statue, supposedly Greek and from the sixth century B.C. Possibly the statue is genuine but undocumented because it was recently unearthed or because it has been privately owned. However, an ancient surface usually has uneven weathering, whereas the surface of this statue has the uniform quality characteristically produced by a chemical bath used by forgers to imitate a weathered surface. Therefore, the statue is probably a forgery.

Which of the following, if true, most seriously weakens the argument?

(A) Museums can accept a recently unearthed statue only with valid export documentation from its country of origin.
(B) The subject’s pose and other aspects of the subject’s treatment exhibit all the most common features of Greek statues of the sixth century B.C.
(C) The chemical bath that forgers use was at one time used by dealers and collectors to remove the splotchy surface appearance of genuinely ancient sculptures.
(D) Museum officials believe that forgers have no technique that can convincingly simulate the patchy weathering characteristic of the surfaces of ancient sculptures.
(E) An allegedly Roman sculpture with a uniform surface similar to that of the stature being offered to the museum was recently shown to be a forgery.
答案是C。而D選項的意思和og對D的解釋看不懂,可否幫我指點一下。
Choice D indicates that a statue that showed uneven weathering would not be a forgery. Since the statue in question does not have uneven weathering, this choice leaves the argument unaffected, and is therefore incorrect.



拍屑,我是Jessy,按引言變成編輯....順便改一下問題標題...

[Jessy]

(D) Museum officials believe that forgers have no technique(博物館的人認為偽造者缺乏某種技術) that can convincingly simulate the patchy weathering characteristic of the surfaces of ancient sculptures.(可以漂亮偽造出自然風化的表面)

Choice D indicates that a statue that showed uneven weathering would not be a forgery. Since the statue in question does not have uneven weathering, this choice leaves the argument unaffected, and is therefore incorrect.
OG對d的選項就是無關選項(unaffected)

怎麼漏掉了這一題...讓你久等了...

[odinhsu]

D的選項是一種錯誤選項的種類
某某人相信,某某人認為,某某人喜 歡....,某某人不喜歡
這種答案通常不會對....
當然問題如果反過來問這種答案反而是正確答案喔!!!
ex:
假設問題問你下列那個答案能支持A造成B
如果有個選項是 某科學家認為A可以造成B
這個選項一定是錯的!!
如果它問你那個選項最不能支持
那麼這個選項就有可能是對的..

[davidlee0222]

D博館官員認為:
偽造者並沒有那種可模仿古雕刻表面特性的”幾可亂真斑白技術”

解答說
D指有斑白的雕像是偽造的
但因為提中沒提到雕像是不是有斑白
所以此選項無關