[問題]OG92

[sisco]

拜託大大們指導一下吧

[維尼]

請教

So many as 用於否定句
As many as 用於肯定句 對嗎

但 Never 不是也有定的意思嗎

急問

我沒聽過這種說法耶
你可以舉一下你在哪邊看到過這樣的說法嗎?

as .. as 是同級比較
so .. as 就沒印象了 只記得 so ... as to ...

[davidlee0222]

so many as是用在否定句法沒錯
as many as要用在肯定句

[jmyang]

so many as是用在否定句法沒錯
as many as要用在肯定句

OG10th 105.

so much as is considered idiomatic if it is preceded by a negative, as in "She left not so much as a trace."

[modern]

這個用法　
老莫有次在解題時直接說" 沒有 so many as / so much as 這個用法,
不選"　害我驚了一下 筆記抄的一愣一愣@@

還好後來腦袋中的疑惑有迫使我回去查OG 確定此用法可用在否定句

不過一般而言要排除選項的話　只要在肯定句中看到so many/much .... as就直接cross out 確實是一個做題技巧 而在考題中很高機率可以用此法排除選項

[mmmlovely]

[quote="davidlee0222"]so many as是用在否定句法沒錯
as many as要用在肯定句[/quote]

as many/much as應該是肯定和否定皆可喔...

Collins Cobuild English Dictionary:

As:2 ou use the structure as....as when you are comparing things.

eg:There is no obvious reason why this could not be as good a film as the original.

from CD

[wing3315]

92. Never before had taxpayers confronted so many changes at once as they had in the Tax Reform Act of 1986.
(A)so many changes at once as they had in
(B)at once as many changes as
(C)at once as many changes that there were with
(D)as many changes at once as they confronted in
(E)so many changes at once that confronted them in
ANS:D

請教

So many as 用於否定句
As many as 用於肯定句 對嗎

但 Never 不是也有定的意思嗎

急問

各位大大您好，
我想請教關於原級比較的用法
莫北北有說過：
1.肯定句 as + 原級形容詞或是副詞 + as
2.否定句 not so +原級形容詞或副詞 + as

我想請問這樣的文法是否與本題的用法是相同的??
但題中的never不是也帶有否定的意味嗎??
拜託各位前輩幫我解惑阿

[dibert8]

(D)as many changes at once as they confronted in
第一個 as 是副詞; 第二個 as 是連接詞(接獨立子句), 有時也當關係代名詞; 當後者解時 as = changes.

[larry.tw]

92. Never before had taxpayers confronted so many changes at once as they had in the Tax Reform Act of 1986.
(A)so many changes at once as they had in
(B)at once as many changes as
(C)at once as many changes that there were with
(D)as many changes at once as they confronted in
(E)so many changes at once that confronted them in
ANS:D

想請問一下B選項
1.at once的位置擺到前面有什麼差嗎?
2.as many changes as 後面沒有接東西,會導致跟誰比??怎麼看??

麻煩了...我ㄧ定要把可惡的as as搞懂....

[pauline_chiou]

原句： Taxpayers had never confronted(動作先) as many changes at once before as(受格＝changes) they(=taxpayers) confronted(動作後) in the Tax Reform Act of 1986.

B選項的 at once 會造成雙向修飾 confronted 和 changes