[問題]考古題 Form 26 -Q22

[cg]

22. The domesticated camel, which some scholars date around the twelfth century B.C., was the key to the development of the spice trade in the ancient world.

B. The domesticated camel, which some scholars have thought to occur
C. Domesticating the camel, dated by some scholars at
D. The domestication of the camel, thought by some scholars to have occurred
E. The camel’s domestication, dated by some scholars to have been

C D E 三者最大的差異，應該是在動詞的使用
不知道哪為高手 可以幫我解釋一下

還有 是不是主詞的表示方式 也影響答案的選項呢

答案是 D

[Pufa]

我只看過sth. dated by sth.的用法，沒看過sth. dated by sb.的用法，用google查查看有沒有類似例句。

C. Domestication of the camel, dated by some scholars at around the twelfth century B.C.,
Domestication前面沒有(定)冠詞，錯。
有at又有around，錯。

E. The camel’s domestication, dated by some scholars to have been around the twelfth century B.C.,
人以外的所有格要用 sth. of sth.。

有沒有說漏說錯的，請前輩指教。

[bugubugu]

我只看過sth. dated by sth.的用法，沒看過sth. dated by sb.的用法，用google查查看有沒有類似例句。

C. Domestication of the camel, dated by some scholars at around the twelfth century B.C.,
Domestication前面沒有(定)冠詞，錯。
有at又有around，錯。

E. The camel’s domestication, dated by some scholars to have been around the twelfth century B.C.,
人以外的所有格要用 sth. of sth.。

有沒有說漏說錯的，請前輩指教。

嗯....
我查字典好像可以dated by人耶...
不過追朔要用date from+時間...
所以我覺得ACE錯是因為沒有用from這個介係詞...

ps.原發問同學可補上全部選像好讓大家解題嗎?
謝謝!

[cg]

我只看過sth. dated by sth.的用法，沒看過sth. dated by sb.的用法，用google查查看有沒有類似例句。

C. Domestication of the camel, dated by some scholars at around the twelfth century B.C.,
Domestication前面沒有(定)冠詞，錯。
有at又有around，錯。

E. The camel’s domestication, dated by some scholars to have been around the twelfth century B.C.,
人以外的所有格要用 sth. of sth.。

有沒有說漏說錯的，請前輩指教。

不好意思
我赫然發現我C題目有寫錯
他是用動詞的方式
A B 一開始就可以刪掉是因為修飾語誤置 以及主詞是Camel有明顯的句意不對

我記得老莫好像是用 have occured來區分選項
但是當時太不認真 沒把上課內容抄下來

[Jackson0317]

我覺得D對的地方是慣用語的用法:

The domestication of the camle, thought by some scholars to have occurred

這裡的用法是堆測動詞, 這個動作occur已經在 12cen D.C.完成了.

這樣看B也可以馬上刪掉.