[問題]考古Form19-Q5

[blue123736]

Baseball is unique for the major sports because it is the only ball game in which the team does not have possession of the ball on offense.

(C) among major sports as the only ball game that the team on offense does not have possession of the ball
(D)among major sports in that it is the only ball game in which the team on offense does not have possession of the ball

答案是D
我只想問各簡單的小問題
C的 as 不能當"因為"解嗎？？

[blue123736]

想想 這問題好像問的有點白癡

不管了 PO就PO了

[魚]

Baseball is unique for the major sports because it is the only ball game in which the team does not have possession of the ball on offense.

(C) among major sports as the only ball game (that the team on offense does not have possession of the ball)


答案是D
我只想問各簡單的小問題
C的 as 不能當"因為"解嗎？？

(C) among major sports as the only ball game (that the team on offense does not have possession of the ball)

blue123736 我想你也知道答案了吧 ~ 找不到動詞 ^^ 是嗎 ?

[cg]

今天翻字典，終於發現offense的意義，小常識供參考(大概只有我不知道 )
from COBUILD

In American English, in sports such as American football, or basketball, the offense is the team which has possession of the call and is trying to score.

[cleashen]

我想請問一下
(D)among major sports in that is the only ball game in which the team on offense does not have possession of the ball

這樣in that後面就沒有主詞是嗎??
不知道為什麼念起來覺得怪怪的

用法是否等同於
S+V, because S+V
=S+V because V

又請問 (B)錯在哪邊呢??

(B)for the major sports in that it is the only ball game the team on offense does not have possession of the ball

是for 跟 among的用法不同嗎??
請大家幫忙指教 感謝~~

[hibettychen]

Baseball is unique for the major sports because it is the only ball game in whihc the team does not have possession of the ball on offense.

(C) among major sports...
(E) among the major sports....

請問一下用for...或是用among...接是否有什麼不同，或是可以除錯的法則呢？

[evelyn_yeh]

用for跟用among翻譯起來,意思就不一樣了.
Baseball is unique for major sports --B 對MS而言是獨特的
Baseball is unique among major sports --B 在MS之中是算獨特的
此題是說Baseball 跟其他sports 的不同

[antimissle]

那C選項的as可以作"身為"解釋嗎? 那感覺還滿順的

D的"in that" OG11th 不是說 overly formal
而且也沒主詞??

[racherlin]

這題的句意不知道那位可以講解一下?看不懂呢...

[A級垂耳兔]

在主流運動中棒球是獨特的..因為這是只有防守球隊沒有持球的球賽
in that=because....in that 是古字...過於正式...OG11已經視為錯誤答案...
所以我想以後應該不會有這種答案了~~~

[keane0727]

用for跟用among翻譯起來,意思就不一樣了.
Baseball is unique for major sports --B 對MS而言是獨特的
Baseball is unique among major sports --B 在MS之中是算獨特的
此題是說Baseball 跟其他sports 的不同

小小的問題：為什麼句意是說明Baseball是獨特的major sports, 能不能以Baseball is unique for major sports起文？

for = concering; considering the nature or usual character of (American Heritage Dictionary)

example

1. "Evolution" is very striking and beautiful, and unique for films in the genre.

2. The waterfalls along the designated scenic section of the Niobrara River are a favorite of visiting tourists. Photos of the waterfalls, particularly Smith Falls , can be found in many publications. Parts of their charm is the result of the geometry being convex downstream which is unique for waterfalls.

3. The pattern of atmospheric dispersion is also unique for cities located in river valleys, coastal areas, or mountain valleys.

4. Gerald Schwartz School is unique for universities in that it combines business and information technology in one school.


以上例子是我在網站上找到的, 此處for不就當when one consider the usual charater of嗎？

Considering the usual character of major sports, Baseball is unique in that it is the only ball game in which the team on the deffense does not have possessiion of the ball.　
個人認為以上句意沒有問題，unique for 的用法可能無誤。