OG-174

[Pufa]

A letter by Mark Twain, written in the same year as The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn were published, reveals that Twain provided financial assistance to one of the first Black students at Yale Law School.
(A) A letter by Mark Twain, written in the same year as The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn were published,
(B) A letter by Mark Twain, written in the same year of publication as The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn,
(C) A letter by Mark Twain, written in the same year that The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn was published,
(D) Mark Twain wrote a letter in the same year as he published The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn that
(E) Mark Twain wrote a letter in the same year of publication as The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn that

答案是C。

CD上對這題的看法分成兩派
一派認為應該用that子句來說明前面的year。這和OG的看法相同。
一派則認為這題應該是把兩個『年』拿來比較。這派的人認為A也可以，但我覺得把A改成：
A letter by Mark Twain, written in the same year as the year when The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn were published,
這樣才對(雖然有點囉唆)。請問這種改法正確嗎？你們的看法如何？

問題很笨

[Pufa]

對於as有幾個看法請大家指正：

用做比較時
like只能接名詞 Like Peter, John.....
as只能接子句 John does...., as Peter does....

表達時間
as表示一段長時間
when表示兩個動作同時發生
while兩個動作同時進行

關係代名詞用法
as....as.....

再看看OG174的A，似乎是the same as + noun. 的固定用法

請大家指點我一下

[micht]

a) 要用"The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn" was published ~~~書名..單數

主要就是were 錯 如果修正的話 應該就可行

[Pufa]

恩恩^^
因為我看到OG裡寫了一句
Choices A and D incorrectly substitute as for that to introduce the relative clause.
想問問看改寫之後是不是可以以另一個用法過關

[soami]

A letter by Mark Twain, written in the same year as The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn were published, reveals that Twain provided financial assistance to one of the first Black students at Yale Law School.
(A) A letter by Mark Twain, written in the same year as The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn were published,
(B) A letter by Mark Twain, written in the same year of publication as The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn,
(C) A letter by Mark Twain, written in the same year that The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn was published,
(D) Mark Twain wrote a letter in the same year as he published The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn that
(E) Mark Twain wrote a letter in the same year of publication as The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn that

答案是C。

CD上對這題的看法分成兩派
一派認為應該用that子句來說明前面的year。這和OG的看法相同。
一派則認為這題應該是把兩個『年』拿來比較。這派的人認為A也可以，但我覺得把A改成：
A letter by Mark Twain, written in the same year as the year when The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn were published,
這樣才對(雖然有點囉唆)。請問這種改法正確嗎？你們的看法如何？

問題很笨

剛剛上去CD查了一下，發現這個說法：when、that都可以拿來做引導時間的介詞

差別用法是在 in the same year ( )...was published
括號內填that比較好

如果要用when的話
19xx is the same year (when) .... was publish

不知道大家意見如何

[odinhsu]

我覺得這裡應該不能用as...
莫北北不是有說
The pen is the same that I lost 這隻筆就是我掉的那隻
The pen is the same as I lost 這隻筆跟我掉的那隻一樣 (言下之意有兩隻筆)
如果年份用as的話....那不就表示有兩個 .....2000,2001,2002.....年
很怪...

[cocaine]

A letter by Mark Twain, written in the same year as The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn were published, reveals that Twain provided financial assistance to one of the first Black students at Yale Law School.
(A) A letter by Mark Twain, written in the same year as The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn were published,
(B) A letter by Mark Twain, written in the same year of publication as The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn,
(C) A letter by Mark Twain, written in the same year that The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn was published,
(D) Mark Twain wrote a letter in the same year as he published The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn that
(E) Mark Twain wrote a letter in the same year of publication as The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn that

答案是C。

CD上對這題的看法分成兩派
一派認為應該用that子句來說明前面的year。這和OG的看法相同。
一派則認為這題應該是把兩個『年』拿來比較。這派的人認為A也可以，但我覺得把A改成：
A letter by Mark Twain, written in the same year as the year when The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn were published,
這樣才對(雖然有點囉唆)。請問這種改法正確嗎？你們的看法如何？

問題很笨

剛剛上去CD查了一下，發現這個說法：when、that都可以拿來做引導時間的介詞

差別用法是在 in the same year ( )...was published
括號內填that比較好

如果要用when的話
19xx is the same year (when) .... was publish

不知道大家意見如何

認同..不過我覺得19xx is (the same)the year (when) .... was publish
那各the same也不用就ok了..因為when就是說the year那各時間點.

[Pufa]

A letter by Mark Twain, written in the same year as The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn were published, reveals that Twain provided financial assistance to one of the first Black students at Yale Law School.
(A) A letter by Mark Twain, written in the same year as The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn were published,
(B) A letter by Mark Twain, written in the same year of publication as The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn,
(C) A letter by Mark Twain, written in the same year that The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn was published,
(D) Mark Twain wrote a letter in the same year as he published The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn that
(E) Mark Twain wrote a letter in the same year of publication as The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn that

答案是C。

CD上對這題的看法分成兩派
一派認為應該用that子句來說明前面的year。這和OG的看法相同。
一派則認為這題應該是把兩個『年』拿來比較。這派的人認為A也可以，但我覺得把A改成：
A letter by Mark Twain, written in the same year as the year when The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn were published,
這樣才對(雖然有點囉唆)。請問這種改法正確嗎？你們的看法如何？

問題很笨

剛剛上去CD查了一下，發現這個說法：when、that都可以拿來做引導時間的介詞

差別用法是在 in the same year ( )...was published
括號內填that比較好
可不可以解釋一下為何that較好呢？我認為在這裡用that或是when都沒差別耶。

如果要用when的話
19xx is the same year (when) .... was publish
同意，這樣改也可以。
不知道大家意見如何

[soami]

A letter by Mark Twain, written in the same year as The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn were published, reveals that Twain provided financial assistance to one of the first Black students at Yale Law School.
(A) A letter by Mark Twain, written in the same year as The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn were published,
(B) A letter by Mark Twain, written in the same year of publication as The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn,
(C) A letter by Mark Twain, written in the same year that The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn was published,
(D) Mark Twain wrote a letter in the same year as he published The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn that
(E) Mark Twain wrote a letter in the same year of publication as The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn that

答案是C。

CD上對這題的看法分成兩派
一派認為應該用that子句來說明前面的year。這和OG的看法相同。
一派則認為這題應該是把兩個『年』拿來比較。這派的人認為A也可以，但我覺得把A改成：
A letter by Mark Twain, written in the same year as the year when The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn were published,
這樣才對(雖然有點囉唆)。請問這種改法正確嗎？你們的看法如何？

問題很笨

剛剛上去CD查了一下，發現這個說法：when、that都可以拿來做引導時間的介詞

差別用法是在 in the same year ( )...was published
括號內填that比較好
可不可以解釋一下為何that較好呢？我認為在這裡用that或是when都沒差別耶。

如果要用when的話
19xx is the same year (when) .... was publish
同意，這樣改也可以。
不知道大家意見如何

xxx was written in the year that ... was published
It is the year when ... was punlished.

感覺it is 是在強調那個年，that則在引導the year，二者應該有細微的差異
可是我說不出來 ，等等去查查文法書好了。

[dibert8]

如果 that = when, 我也頗有同感. 這麼說 that 在此當連接詞, 引導形副詞子句, 修飾 written in the same year, 還是當關係代名詞(代替誰?), 引導關係(形容詞)子句, 修飾 year?

[hwatai]

(A)如果改成...written in the same year as The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn was written. 就是對的，was written可以省略

但由於(A)是published，而不是written
當前後動詞一致時，才能夠使用same... as...; 如果不一致，就換用that

請繼續討論吧

[dibert8]

不好意思!看到 the same... that 有所頓悟,自己來糾正自己提的問題.
that 子句作 year 的同位語,因此是名詞子句.

[larry.tw]

回上樓的,
不對喔,that應該是形容詞子句
in the same year that(關代,當後面的受詞) The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn was published
==>The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn was published in the same year

[dibert8]

that... = year (說明 year)
被動語句沒有受詞.
(Tip: GMAT 的句子裡,當受詞的關代經常省略. i.e. that 不會無緣無故出現,如果是正確選項,它一定不能省略.)