請問GWD3 Q1

[amyshen]

Q1:
The four-million-year-old fossilized skeleton known as Lucy is so small compared with many other skeletons presumed to be of the same species, and so some paleontologists have argued that Lucy represents a different lineage.

A. presumed to be of the same species, and so
B. presumed to be of the same species that
C. presumed that they are of the same species, and so
D. that they have presumed to be of the same species, so that
E. that they have presumed are of the same species, and

這題答案是B...我選A....請問B中的最後一個字是that......A最後一個字so...不是比較好嗎???? SO....that .... 還是我會錯意了

[Behemoth]

前面未畫線部分已經有so囉
片語是so...that...
不是so..so...that...

[amyshen]

我漏看ㄌ..真是ㄉ....哈

[agk99]

另一個錯誤則是and的平衡 ...A沒有

[hungji]

(錯誤請指正)
1. 快速比較5個答案
2. and so, so that, and, are, that 子句.
3. 看題目, so 出現了, 找 that 子句, 刪 A,C
4. E 中 are 的主詞是誰? 刪 E
5. D 改變句意, B短又好, 選 B, B對了, 莫北北萬歲

[CUGGYER]

請問 presume有哪些用法阿
他是不是不能用presume that
還是因為這題的they可省略 才用presume to be

至於de的時態錯誤是因為presume不能持續 所以才錯嗎?
雖然選對 可是肚子裡一堆疑問

[maronchen1103]

BD比較看句意吧
presumed to be of the same species是形容skeletons
所以是在比skeletions known as Lucy compared with skeletons presume presumed to be of the same species
後面才接that子句呼應so


有錯請指正

[dreamkid]

咦...我用編輯修正...為什麼會多出一篇呢？

[dreamkid]

Q1:
The four-million-year-old fossilized skeleton known as Lucy is so small compared with many other skeletons presumed to be of the same species, and so some paleontologists have argued that Lucy represents a different lineage.

A. presumed to be of the same species, and so
B. presumed to be of the same species that
C. presumed that they are of the same species, and so
D. that they have presumed to be of the same species, so that
E. that they have presumed are of the same species, and

這題答案是B...我選A....請問B中的最後一個字是that......A最後一個字so...不是比較好嗎???? SO....that .... 還是我會錯意了

三者以上平行，and前才可加逗號(非插入句)==>刪A,C,E
D的代名詞用複數they，只可能代前面的other skeletons，裡面動詞卻又用主動態==>刪
答案B

[小隻]

請問 B) presumed to be of the same species that的of 從哪來?
TKS!

[agustin]

請問 B) presumed to be of the same species that的of 從哪來?
TKS!

省略而來

...compared with many other skeletons (which are)presumed to be skeletons of the same species that...

which are 省略 presume改過去分詞presumed 表被動

to be skeletons of the same species 是受詞 整個視為同一物
但是skeletons前面提過了 可以省略不說
[tab][tab]

[agustin]

其實這一題有很大的問題耶 怎麼都沒人問...><
小弟不才 來總結一下這題
這題的考點在so...that...結構 跟that 名詞子句混淆一起考
要考判斷能力

前面有人用平衡結構去作 恩 是很有效率沒錯
不過個人意見認為 這是很危險的 因為你可能誤判 第一時間就消去了正確答案 事實上 不是所有用連結詞的句子都該平衡
而且 萬一出現四五個and呢? 你不找死了嗎 到底是那個and該平衡?
我是認為平衡法不要中毒太深 起碼不要第一時間就用...會非常的武斷危險

A選項不談了 完全沒出現that 沒有任何正確的可能 所以不花時間拆它

B) The skeleton is so small....that 結果 文意/結構都合理 留下

C)...many other skeletons presumed that they are of the same species, and so
--that是名詞子句 當動詞 presume的受格 則缺少so...that...結構 不正確

D)...many other skeletons that they have presumed....,so that
--that子句為skeletons的名詞子句 修飾skeletons
整句 S is so small...., so that...<---找不到第一個so該有的that
再說 D有句意問題 they(seletons)應是被presumed 要被動

E)...many other skeletons that they have presumed....,and
--同D that判斷為skeletons的名詞子句 修飾skeletons
則缺乏so....that...結構
E也有句意問題 they(seletons)應是被presumed 要被動

[tab][tab]

[Miranda's]

(錯誤請指正)
1. 快速比較5個答案
2. and so, so that, and, are, that 子句.
3. 看題目, so 出現了, 找 that 子句, 刪 A,C
4. E 中 are 的主詞是誰? 刪 E
5. D 改變句意, B短又好, 選 B, B對了, 莫北北萬歲

請問，D改變句意是指沒有so...that... 如此...以致於... 的句意了嗎？請賜教^^ 3Q！

[carollai]

(錯誤請指正)
1. 快速比較5個答案
2. and so, so that, and, are, that 子句.
3. 看題目, so 出現了, 找 that 子句, 刪 A,C
4. E 中 are 的主詞是誰? 刪 E
5. D 改變句意, B短又好, 選 B, B對了, 莫北北萬歲

請問，D改變句意是指沒有so...that... 如此...以致於... 的句意了嗎？請賜教^^ 3Q！

應該說 so small compared with many other skeletons that they have presumed to be of the same species, so that
紅色they能帶的只有many other skeletons 但是他們會主動去presume嗎 不會吧 所以句意改變了 我想應該是這樣吧 哈

[Miranda's]

(錯誤請指正)
1. 快速比較5個答案
2. and so, so that, and, are, that 子句.
3. 看題目, so 出現了, 找 that 子句, 刪 A,C
4. E 中 are 的主詞是誰? 刪 E
5. D 改變句意, B短又好, 選 B, B對了, 莫北北萬歲

請問，D改變句意是指沒有so...that... 如此...以致於... 的句意了嗎？請賜教^^ 3Q！

應該說 so small compared with many other skeletons that they have presumed to be of the same species, so that
紅色they能帶的只有many other skeletons 但是他們會主動去presume嗎 不會吧 所以句意改變了 我想應該是這樣吧 哈

3Q~我懂了，很清楚的解釋^^