GWD1-Q17

[Grace]

HI All,

First, thanks for Illuna's explaination of her CR teacher.
I will ask our CR teacher--Mr. Chen on Saturday, and get you to your guys soon.
I am still looking for a convining explaination.

[illuna]

HI All,

First, thanks for Illuna's explaination of her :o CR teacher.

我是男的...... :|

I will ask our CR teacher--Mr. Chen on Saturday, and get you to your guys soon.
I am still looking for a convining explaination.

靜候佳音....不過老實說我覺得這題真的很不明顯....

[Grace]

Oh...God...... (6)
我一直以為你是女的....
應該是受照片的靚女影響吧....
真是不好意思 :-$
大哥原諒囉....

ps. Tell you a secret, I thought fish is a "boy" rather than a "gril".

[魚]

Oh...God...... (6)
我一直以為你是女的....
應該是受照片的靚女影響吧....
真是不好意思 :-$
大哥原諒囉....

ps. Tell you a secret, I thought fish is a "boy" rather than a "gril".

:D Grace北鼻 : 妮的 secret 也太明目張膽了吧 :P

[nana]

唉攸喂阿~
我看了半天還是不知道到底該選哪個好
這題可以大膽的總結答案是E嗎........
help~

[micht]

Q17:
The spacing of the four holes on a fragment of a bone flute excavated at a Neanderthal campsite is just what is required to play the third through sixth notes of the diatonic scale—the seven-note musical scale used in much of Western music since the Renaissance. Musicologists therefore hypothesize that the diatonic musical scale was developed and used thousands of years before it was adopted by Western musicians.

Which of the following, if true, most strongly supports the hypothesis


我偏向(E)

過去發現
a fragment of a bone flute excavated at a Neanderthal campsite
(有四個動可吹出 third through sixth notes)

作者假設
the diatonic musical scale was developed and used thousands of years before it was adopted by Western musicians

原因是... 古代可能就有使用了

B. No musical instrument that is known to have used a diatomic scale is of an earlier date than the flute found at the Neanderthal campsite.

沒有任何東西比 可以吹出 diatonmic scale [比Neanderthal campsite]
那幾時 有人使用 7 notes呢??? 不知道~有可能從 Neaderthal campsite 到Western Renaissance前都仍只可以用 third through sixth notes? 何時啟用不知道~ during Western Renaissance也說不定

只知道比Neaderthal campsite還早以前沒人用 不知道何時開始用?



E.The cave-bear leg bone used to make the Neanderthal flute would have been long enough to make a flute capable of playing a complete diatonic scale.

骨頭夠長可以吹出7notes (complete diatonic scale)
則可以support做者的假設~可能過去就有人吹 complete diatonic scale



我的一點想法

[nana]

謝謝金剛妹
我懂意思了 :D

[Grace]

這一題我先前問過老師.他的答案是E沒錯!!

[游客]

這題B選項,應該是屬於out of scope
看似合理,但對主要對象bone flute卻沒有起直接的作用
ETD標準渾淆選項
煩阿....

[yanguoeric]

大家有沒有注意到題目 a fragment of a bone flute
而E 說的論點 腿骨夠長 長到足以作成一隻可以完全吹奏七聲音階的flute
所以我覺得這個論點很能支持題目
小的 小小看法 請不另指教
p.s. 偶第一次作也是選b

[維尼]

最近終於做了第一回GWD
關於這題的答案
我個人也是在BE之間選擇
後來想起補習班老師在講到OG #82的時候
就補充了這一題
他還特別請同學兩相對照一下
就會赫然發現
這兩題背後的concept非常接近
連BE答案的出法都很接近
所以
如果以OG #82去猜測ETS的思路的話
他認為選B對的機會是比較大的

PS: 不過人家寄給我的咖啡店版本解答還是E @_@

[evelight]

我支持答案為E
因為E直接增強全音階和骨笛的關聯性。

B說的是: 沒有一個全音階樂器在年代上早於尼安德人的骨笛。
這意味著兩種可能:
1. 人類史上第一個全音階樂器是在尼安德人後發展
或者
2. 尼安德人的骨笛就是第一個全音階樂器

兩種都合理，但是後者支持結論、前者不支持
這就好像Math的資料充分性一樣
如果一個條件可導致兩種答案，這個條件就不能選

[liwuu]

我最後一次考at時有遇到這一題...我當時選E,現在看一看還是投E一票!!

[維尼]

除了利用OG 82去揣測ETS的思路外
我不支持E的理由還有另一個:
既然那塊骨頭夠長 可是卻"只"打了四個洞
讓它"只"能 play the third through sixth notes of the diatonic scale
而不是 play all notes
這樣想的話
E甚至有 weaken 的感覺: 器材可以卻沒做 可能是因為還沒發展出 diatonic scale

[sleek]

Q17:
the seven-note musical scale used [size=18]in much of Western music since the Renaissance.quote]

I think Grace's explanation mab be correct.
In my opinion
This question foucus on note (E) and not on the time of intrument.(B)
According to the article, we know that the seven-note scale used not much before Renaissance.
However, E present the powerful evidence to support that the seven-note scale had used but not often before Renaissance.

That's really a typical ets bull-shit question. :-S

十分同意MIKE之This question foucus on note (E) and not on the time of intrument.(B)
且以B選項而言
能support the hypothesis,但反向思考如No musical instrument...改成 A musical instrument 或 Some musical instrument, 對結論會產生weaken嗎? 並不會,因為都會是thousands of years before

以E選項而言
題目給了一個事實"a fragment"--音階3-6
選項中又給我們一個線索"would have been long enough to"--音階 1-7
就可推論出如題目中音樂家的假設!
個人覺得E選項的would並不妥,因為題目是"hypothesis"

如有錯誤,煩請指正