大全 Q.315

[liwuu]

Framed by traitorous colleagues, Alfred Dreyfus was imprisoned for twelve years before there was exoneration and his freedom.
a.there was exoneration and his freedom
b.he was to be exonerated with freedom
c.being exonerated and freed
d.exoneration and his freedom
e.being freed, having been exonerated

答案是C
請教一下,有關B部份的was to be為什麼不對?!幫朋友問的,因為朋友不滿意我對選項b的解釋,另外我C,D決戰,最後選D...sc真難!!

[Pufa]

猛一看我還以為五哥又要考試了-.-"，我來放個地雷囉~

(B) he was to be exonerated with freedom.
我認為這得跟前面的before一起看才行：
before being exonerated and freed -- 在他被釋放之前。
before he was to be exonerated with freedom -- 在他即將被釋放之前。
所以加了was to be有種很多餘的感覺。
B選項用be exonerated "with" freedom排除比較快。

說到C...要不是being前面是years，我還真不敢選.....

[liwuu]

猛一看我還以為五哥又要考試了-.-"，我來放個地雷囉~

(B) he was to be exonerated with freedom.
我認為這得跟前面的before一起看才行：
before being exonerated and freed -- 在他被釋放之前。
before he was to be exonerated with freedom -- 在他即將被釋放之前。
所以加了was to be有種很多餘的感覺。
B選項用be exonerated "with" freedom排除比較快。

說到C...要不是being前面是years，我還真不敢選.....

呵呵...P老大,我對B的解釋跟你一樣...這個地雷變成子母雷囉!!
另外,有關D,我當初就是不太敢選C那個being,所以就選D下去,然後自我安慰選項D的名詞平衡簡潔俐落...就這樣掛了!!

[Pufa]

看來你眼花啦~哈哈
d.exoneration and his freedom
exoneration前面沒有an, the or his啦。

[Jen-Cheng]

說到C...要不是being前面是years，我還真不敢選.....


為什麼啊??有什麼奧妙在裡面？？