[問題]天山3-15

[puthing]

Q15:
The population of India has been steadily increasing for decades, and it will probably have what is estimated as 1.6 billion people by 2050 and surpass China as the world’s
most populous nation.

A. it will probably have what is estimated as
B. they are likely to have
C. the country will probably have
D. there will probably be
E. there will be an estimated

ans:(C)

想問一下(D)不好在哪裡?

指代(or句意)不清楚嗎?

可是india前面又已經提到過了

笨笨的問

請大家不要笑我

[Pufa]

ㄟ....
幫你頂一下，
我也不知道為什麼，剛剛做這題，想都沒想就選C了。

當時我腦子裡的聲音是"Pufa阿...句子後面有個china，你前面就安排個country跟他對比吧...."

[christina]

是不是?? 後面再接了一句....and surpass China as the world’s
most populous nation.
的緣故,所以不能用there will ...而要用the country will...
:)

[CUGGYER]

請問那A是錯在哪裡阿>< 我最後是AC選一個 還是選到錯的

[Pufa]

請問那A是錯在哪裡阿>< 我最後是AC選一個 還是選到錯的

what is estimated as 1.6 million people.
文法好像怪怪的，似乎有錯的地方，一時說不上來。
即使文法沒錯，這表達方式也太囉唆了。

[puthing]

1.estimated as 不是idiomatic 的用法

2.it如果代The population of India

變成The population of India擁有多少萬人而不是india這國家擁有多少萬人

人口感覺起來是個數字

應該不能做"擁有"這動作


what的部分我也還不太懂

所以不明白有沒有錯

還請大家繼續指教

[stilalala]

Q15:
The population of India has been steadily increasing for decades, and it will probably have what is estimated as 1.6 billion people by 2050 and surpass China as the world’s
most populous nation.

A. it will probably have what is estimated as
B. they are likely to have
C. the country will probably have
D. there will probably be
E. there will be an estimated

ans:(C)

想問一下(D)不好在哪裡?

指代(or句意)不清楚嗎?

可是india前面又已經提到過了

笨笨的問

請大家不要笑我

說說我選c的方法
麻煩大家幫忙看看是否正確
a. it指誰?? 如果指Population og India 的話,後面沒有劃線的部分有
surpass China "as the world's most populous nation "
一個人口最多的國家---前面邏輯主語一定要放india才會正確
再者,estimate as 是不符合慣用語法了

b they=??
c. the country明確指代India, India 將有可能擁有多人人...正確表達方式

d.e there be --導致後面as a nation無主語可代

請多多指教
謝謝

[FIG]

這題我本來選D
檢討時發現D的句意很有問題，不知算不算比較不同類
1.6 billion people surpass china ，人數不會超過國家

[dibert8]

的確是個好論點.

我做的時候是覺得 there 天馬行空不知指哪裡.現在看看,其實 there 也不能 超過 China 也.