[問題]考古Form14-Q12

[Lian]

Margot Peters' recent study examines the actresses with whom, as a dramatic critic and struggling playwright, Shaw found himself writing for, competing with, courting for their influence, and often simply courting.
(A) with whom, as
(B) with whom, when he was
(c) with whom, being
(D) whom, being
(E) whom, as

Ans:(E)

請問(A)的錯誤為何? 謝謝

[freshmanduke]

whom前不可加任何介係詞
故A錯

[maronchen1103]

我這裡抄的筆記參考一下
先將as a dramatic critic and struggling playwright跳過
主要的whom子句是shaw found himself writing for, competing with, courting for.......

因為後面介詞不同而不可提前with whom, 因此A錯

有講錯的地方請指教~~~~

[michelle610]

同意maronchen1103
whom 是受格形式的關係代名詞 通常用法有
whom+S+V / 介詞+whom+S+V

[米琪]

我這裡抄的筆記參考一下
先將as a dramatic critic and struggling playwright跳過
主要的whom子句是shaw found himself writing for, competing with, courting for.......

因為後面介詞不同而不可提前with whom, 因此A錯

有講錯的地方請指教~~~~

我有點看不太太懂耶~~
這邊有courting for their influence耶
怎麼跟whom所代的actresses扯上關係呢?


還有另一個問題
as引導出來的是同位語嗎?
用來修飾Shaw這個人 對嗎?
那同位語插在那邊可以喔?
這樣子Shaw主詞就跟whom離好遠耶
為什麼這樣子用可以呢?

拜託誰可以幫我解答一 下呢?

[evelyn_yeh]

更正maronchen1103 的一個小小錯誤.
(1)whom是 writing for, competing with, courting 1 and courting 2 的受詞
**courting for their influence其實是courting whom for their influence,所以,whom是courting的受詞,非courting for 的受詞.(courting 是及物動詞喲)
(2)whom 是指actresses,不是Shaw
(3)as引導出來的是同位語,修飾Shaw

[hibettychen]

那我想請問一下，這題...,as...Shaw found himself writing for, competing with, courting for their influence, and often simply courting.

畫線部分是如何出來的呢？and..後面到底是跟誰平衡阿？

[evelyn_yeh]

(1), and often simply courting.and 的前面有(, ),平衡3個以上.
就像我在6樓寫的,平衡4個~writing for, competing with, courting for their influence, and often simply courting. 共4個(Ving1,Ving2,Ving3 and Ving4)
(2)還原就是這樣 writing for 'the actresses" , competing with "actresses" , courting "the actresses" for their influence, and often simply courting "the actresses" .