[問題] Arco Master GMAT CAT 2001

[piyopiyo]

When it rains, my car gets wet. Since it hasn't rained recently, my car can't be wet.

Which of the following is logically most similar to the argument above?

A. Whenever critics give a play a favorable review, people go to see it; Pinter's new play did not receive favorable reviews, so I doubt that anyone will go to see it.

B. Whenever people go to see a play, critics give it a favorable review; people did go to see Pinter's new play, so it did get a favorable review.

C. Whenever critics give a play a favorable review, people go to see it; Pinter's new play got favorable reviews, so people will probably go to see it.

D. Whenever a play is given favorable reviews by the critics, people go to see it; since people are going to see Pinter's new play, it will probably get favorable reviews.

E. Whenever critics give a play a favorable review, people go to see it; people are not going to see Pinter's new play , so it did not get favorable reviews.



Answer: A.


I saw this question in Arco Master the GMAT CAT 2001

I picked C.

I don't understand Why C is incorrect. What's the difference between A and C???

Thank you very much~~~

[liwuu]

邏輯上要求最相近...
題目說當下雨,貓會濕.因為最近沒下雨,所以我的貓可能沒濕
(後面的邏輯在於否定前面的情形下,可能發生的情形)
而A選項亦是如此...
C選項變成是在前面的情形肯定下,可能發生的情形...
所以邏輯上還是以A最為相近

[peche]

C. Whenever critics give a play a favorable review, people go to see it; Pinter's new play got favorable reviews, so people will probably go to see it.

I picked C.

I don't understand Why C is incorrect. What's the difference between A and C???

Thank you very much~~~

錯在probably 這個字上
覺得應該要是 People will go to see it..

再補充一些想法~
When it rains, my car gets wet. Since it hasn't rained recently, my car can't be wet.
-- rain = car gets wet, so -- NO rain = NO wet car

A 選項和 例子都是 先YES 後NO 的推法
( fav review = people go to see it, NO fav reviews = no audience)

[cyrus_tsai]

題目邏輯是
A->B...........所以 不A->不B
當然這是錯的應該是......不B->不A

當然A對囉

[piyopiyo]

Thank you very much~