OG~166

[CUGGYER]

66. The prime lending rate is a key rate in the econ­omy: not only are the interest rates on most loans to small and medium-sized businesses tied to the prime, but also on a growing number of consumer loans, including home equity loans.
(A) not only are the interest rates on most loans to small and medium-sized businesses tied to the prime, but also on
(B) tied to the prime are the interest rates not only on most loans to small and medium-sized businesses, but also on
(C) the interest rates not only on most loans to small and medium-sized businesses are tied to the prime, but also
(D) not only the interest rates on most loans to small and medium-sized businesses are tied to the prime, but also on
(E) the interest rates are tied to the prime, not only on most loans to small and medium-sized businesses, but also

答案是B

想請問自己對 A D 錯誤的理解是否正確

not only 倒裝時 為否定副詞 修飾句子中的動詞
而題目中not only 是修飾 (on most loan)adv
因此倒裝會改變句意 也破壞平衡結構

[agustin]

恩 我覺得你繞遠路了耶

這題不是在考修飾 是單純的考平衡而已

(A) (D)錯是因為不平衡
(A)若要對 應改成not only are the interest rates on......,but also are the interest rates on....
(D)若要對 應改成not only the interest rates on...., but also the interest rates on....

not only...,but also...片語裡面的東西不能提公因式 而且要平衡
若真的覺得累贅 就把重複的東西 拿到片語外面放


否定副詞不一定修飾動詞 也可以修飾整句哦
它的用點是把句意否定掉 修飾誰其實不那麼重要...

[CUGGYER]

不過這句的句意來說
不是應該是
the interest rates are tied to the prime not only on most loans to small and medium-sized businesses, but also on a growing number of consumer loans, including home equity loans.

意思似乎跟您還原的意思不太相同

可能是我問題沒說清楚吧

我的意思是 因為NOT ONLY提前 使AD句意改變
而深究他改變的原因 是否和我上述相同

[agustin]

ok 瞭解

我還原的確是只以文法角度去還原 所以與原題有句意差距

所以是改變句意了

[世界和平]

1.Not only V1 + S1, but also S2 + V2.
=>Not only在句首時用以連接兩主詞不同之子句，第一子句需強制倒裝。
(A) (D) 省略了S2，文法上已不正確。

2. S1 not only V1, but alos V2.
=> 同一主詞所進行的兩種動作或狀態。

另外以1結構所強調的為兩個獨立事件(子句)間之關連性，與題意相左- ~not only on A, but also on B.(強調 同一主詞對對不同事件的影響)

原句:
The interest rates not only on most loans to small and medium-sized businesses, but also on a growing number of consumer loans, including home equity loans, are tied to the prime (lending rate).

[pimi]

原句:
The interest rates not only on most loans to small and medium-sized businesses, but also on a growing number of consumer loans, including home equity loans, are tied to the prime (lending rate).

這樣的結構可以把tied to the prime倒裝到前面的原因是什麼呢??
應該不是所有的句子都可以這樣倒裝吧!
請問大大是怎樣的文法原則使得這句可以這樣倒裝??
因為把個Vpp的單字放到句首, 真的一眼看到就會很想把它給刪掉 > <

[pimi]

原句:
The interest rates not only on most loans to small and medium-sized businesses, but also on a growing number of consumer loans, including home equity loans, are tied to the prime (lending rate).

這樣的結構可以把tied to the prime倒裝到前面的原因是什麼呢??
應該不是所有的句子都可以這樣倒裝吧!
請問大大是怎樣的文法原則使得這句可以這樣倒裝??
因為把個Vpp的單字放到句首, 真的一眼看到就會很想把它給刪掉 > <