[問題]大全 21-9

[lunar916]

Historian: Anyone who thinks that the terrors of the ancient regime of Q were exclusively the work of fanatics is overlooking a basic truth: the regime was made up primarily of ordinary people enthusiastically seeking paradise. The regime executed many people in pursuit of its goal, but it later became clear that paradise as they defined it, is unrealizable. So at least some of the ordinary people of Q were in fact murderers.
Which one of the following principles, if valid, provides the most support for the historian’s argumentation?
(A) The pursuit of paradise does not justify murder.
(B) The pursuit of paradise justifies fanaticism.
(C) Execution in pursuit of what is later found to be unattainable constitutes murder.
(D) Fanaticism in pursuit of paradise constitutes inhumanity.
(E) Enthusiasm in pursuit of what is eventually found to be unattainable constitutes fanaticism.



ans: C

--------------

我選A
感覺A跟C好像差不多,不過C更與passage合身
但我看不出來A哪比C不support

[Pufa]

襪...這題生字真多，得查字典才看的懂。

題目說ordinary people殺了一些人以追求一個天堂。（為了追求天堂而殺人是合法的）
後來發現這天堂不可能實現，所以作者認為那些殺過人的people都是兇手。

A：追求天堂不能讓殺人合理化。
錯！是『天堂不可能實現卻還殺人』才不能讓殺人合理化。

C：其實就是把題目的內容予以證實，所以正確。

[lunar916]

襪...這題生字真多，得查字典才看的懂。

題目說ordinary people殺了一些人以追求一個天堂。（為了追求天堂而殺人是合法的）
後來發現這天堂不可能實現，所以作者認為那些殺過人的people都是兇手。

A：追求天堂不能讓殺人合理化。
錯！是『天堂不可能實現卻還殺人』才不能讓殺人合理化。

C：其實就是把題目的內容予以證實，所以正確。

= =|||.......

可是文章沒有說為了追求天堂而殺人是合法的,只有說有人為了追求天堂而殺人ㄚ~
好難ㄛ~~~
嗚嗚嗚~ 讀老半天都沒啥進步的感覺 好沮喪ㄛ~ >_<

[Pufa]

可是文章沒有說為了追求天堂而殺人是合法的,只有說有人為了追求天堂而殺人ㄚ~

我那樣說這樣說也許太果斷了，換句話說說看，
作者起初對『追求天堂而殺人』這件事沒有特別的意見；
是因為後來發現『那些人的天堂』不可能實現，所以才認為殺人是違法的。