[問題]考古題form22-Q10

[cleashen]

City planners in Detroit hope that the renewal project extending along the eastern riverfront will establish a population that lives and works downtown and also provides the office space needed to attract new business.

(B) to live and work downtown and also provide
(C) that lives as well as works downtown and also provide
(D) which lives as well as works downtown and also provides
(E) who live as well as work downtown and also provides

答案是(C)
想請問一下 我知道 A as well as B 的重點在A 跟A and B有一點不一樣
可是在這題裡面 是怎樣判斷出要用as well as而不用and呢?
(B)的文法好像也沒有錯耶
請大家指教! 謝謝!!

[vivid]

a 錯是因為句尾的provides
既然前面是will establish 後面應該用原形provide才對
as well as 跟and 的區分應該要看句意吧
可惜我資質駑鈍 在這題沒辦法從句意看出不同
b的話 to 是表目的
用來表示population很怪
不如用that來說明population

有錯請多多指教囉^^

[mingwhale]

(B)的選項問題出在
to live and work downtown and also provide
兩個and連在一起，容易使人誤解，將前面改為as well as，與後面的and 區隔，句意更清楚，所以(C)的答案較佳。

[bibbyshiu]

(B)的選項, to live and work. to = in order to. 句意會變為 "為了居住與工作而建立population", 怪怪的
(C)的選項, that lives as well as works, 句意為"建立在那邊生活與工作的人口", 以題意來看, C似乎較佳