考古題 form 21 # 9

由 **Jackson0317** » 2005-11-04 20:36

這題也請大家幫忙一下:

9) As generators of electricity, small, relatively inexpensive windmills shaped like eggbeaters have several advantages over large, propeller-shaped windmills: simplicity, reliability of stressed components, efficiency in converting wind energy and beauty

a) As generators of electricity, small, relatively inexpensive windmills shaped like eggbeaters have several advantages over large, propeller-shaped windmills:
b) As generators of elecricity, several advantages that small, relatively inexpensive windmills shaped like eggbeaters have over large, propeller-shaped windmills include
c) Several advantages that small, relatively inexpensive windmills for generating electricity shaped like eggbeaters have over large, propeller-shaped windmills include
d) several advantages of small, relatively inexpensive windmills shaped like eggbeaters for generating electricity over large, propeller-shaped windmills include
e) Small, relatively inexpensive windmills for generating electricity shaped like eggbeaters have the following several advantages over large, propeller-shaped windmills:

Ans: A

其他選項都有改變句意的嫌疑,但是我覺得A的structure跟As+S+V的用法有衝突.請各位大大解釋一下.

由 **林小馬** » 2005-11-05 01:49

Jackson0317 \$m[1]:
其他選項都有改變句意的嫌疑,但是我覺得A的structure跟As+S+V的用法有衝突.請各位大大解釋一下.

As generators of electricity, small, relatively inexpensive windmills shaped like eggbeaters have several advantages over large, propeller-shaped windmills : simplicity, reliability of stressed components, efficiency in converting wind energy and beauty

我在猜想有沒有可能你是誤會了A的結構啊 :PP

從顏色可以看到A的結構

我把他簡化看你會不會覺得比較清楚
As generators of electricity, small windmills have advantages over large windwills : &()&**(%^*O

所以這邊的AS其實是"比較要同類"的AS

由 **Jackson0317** » 2005-11-05 12:06

以你這樣解釋我同意,但是我check了一下OG的類式比較要同類的題型,As載句首都要用As+S+V的結構. 我好像記的墨老也是這麼講.

由 **林小馬** » 2005-11-05 12:23

Jackson0317 \$m[1]:以你這樣解釋我同意,但是我check了一下OG的類式比較要同類的題型,As載句首都要用As+S+V的結構. 我好像記的墨老也是這麼講.

對不起喔我終於看懂你問什麼了
不好意思呵呵我還自以為是地回答一堆 :PP

我東西忘得太快了~~~~ :PP

我懂你的意思, 你的意思是這裡應該要用like
不然就是在as句型後面後面家個v

我想你說的的確有道理
埃
不過如果我沒記錯,考古題裡違反規則的也不只這題 :PP

我自己後來是放棄考古題 (個人做法沒有褻瀆之意 :PP

逃~~ )

有沒有哪個高手教一下啊~~~~~~

由維尼 » 2005-11-05 13:37

這題不是比較同類
就句意來看
應該是做為電力產生器
比較像是 As a student, I shall study hard.

由 **Jackson0317** » 2005-11-05 23:14

維尼說:

這題不是比較同類
就句意來看
應該是做為電力產生器
比較像是 As a student, I shall study hard.

我覺得以這個句子應該也可以說是比較要同類啊.
As a student, I shall study hard (I 代 student)
我想了想....會不會有可能是倒裝句? 我想這題想了兩天了.....真是想不通!

由維尼 » 2005-11-05 23:21

Jackson0317 \$m[1]:維尼說:

這題不是比較同類
就句意來看
應該是做為電力產生器
比較像是 As a student, I shall study hard.

我覺得以這個句子應該也可以說是比較要同類啊.
As a student, I shall study hard (I 代 student)
我想了想....會不會有可能是倒裝句? 我想這題想了兩天了.....真是想不通!