[問題]GWD18- Q27

[DARY]

One critic's response to the philosopher's new work is not that the position it takes is heretical, as some have asserted, but instead nothing new to anyone who knows anything about the topic.

A. not that the position it takes is heretical, as some have asserted, but instead
B. not that the position it takes is heretical, like some have asserted, but it is
C. not that the position it takes is heretical, as some have asserted, but rather that it is
D. that the position it takes is not heretical, like some have asserted, instead
E. that the position it takes is not heretical, as some have asserted it to be, but rather it is

Ans: C

問題1. as和like用法的區別
2. 請問題意 因為我其實整個不懂這題在說什麼

謝謝大家.

[davidlee0222]

這提非常奸詐
要完全句意解題才解的出來

一批判者對哲學家新作的回應
並不是像某些人指稱的異教立場
而是對任何了解此主題的人來說了無新意

as表"像..."時當連接詞用
要接S+V+O
like表"像.."時是介係詞
後面接N

[bistro]

這題的思路是先從but..... rather than 的句型判斷，找到正確的句型後，判斷平橫，之後就是用 as 與 like 找到正確答案。基本上還沒有透過句意去解，不過了解句意之後的確比較好懂。請參考。

[davidlee0222]

恩
這提的確這樣解快一點
不過這種習慣要相當小心
機考有很多技巧陷阱
組內三位技巧女王都慘敗不到五百

[FiscJanet]

這題的思路是先從but..... rather than 的句型判斷，找到正確的句型後，判斷平橫，之後就是用 as 與 like 找到正確答案。基本上還沒有透過句意去解，不過了解句意之後的確比較好懂。請參考。

好像應該是not A but(rather) B 的句型 "不是 A是B"

[kaori110]

我想請問instead 的用法
but instead 好像都不對耶

[balanana]

可否請教~E錯在哪裡??
not 一定要一開始就接在is的後面嗎?
E. that the position it takes is not heretical,
as some have asserted it to be, but rather it is

我知道as some have asserted it to be這裡很怪,但可否說明這裡文法上是錯哪裡嗎??
謝謝

[kaori110]

可否請教~E錯在哪裡??
not 一定要一開始就接在is的後面嗎?
E. that the position it takes is not heretical,
as some have asserted it to be, but rather it is

我知道as some have asserted it to be這裡很怪,但可否說明這裡文法上是錯哪裡嗎??
謝謝

這裡是 not...but (rather) 的平衡
選(E)的話
就不平衡了
要平衡兩個"that"引導的名詞子句