[問題]2000年1月Q22(structure)

[Janet]

22. Celery, an edible plant is having long stalks topped with feathery leaves, grows best in cool weather.

答案:B;請問B is having 改成 has 對嗎?

[sickkid]

having 才對　is 去掉，　主要的句子是Celery　grows best in cool weather.
中間插入句是修飾主詞Celery　

[Janet]

having 才對　is 去掉，　主要的句子是Celery　grows best in cool weather.
中間插入句是修飾主詞Celery　

感謝sickkid一連post五篇~

看得出Celery grows...是主要主動詞.

我本題主要很困惑在於.補述用法中

連用兩個分辭來修飾,非常不習慣呢!


an edible plant having long stalks topped with feathery leaves

having modify plant
topped with modify stalks


已經離修辭有點遙遠,請問同位語中,不需要有S+V 完整結構嗎?

換句話說,請問同位語中,可以有的結構是什麼?

[sickkid]

已經離修辭有點遙遠,請問同位語中,不需要有S+V 完整結構嗎?

換句話說,請問同位語中,可以有的結構是什麼?

Not really, for example:

John, my friend, was absent today.


your question varis a a lot of aspects.....

well, I am unable to answer specifically.

How about referring to a grammar book?

[Janet]

Thanks~~~I'll check it out~~~