[問題]Prep-T1-Q128

[dibert8]

128.

According to a study published in The New England Journal of Medicine, aspirin prevents blood clots just as well as a commonly used and more expensive blood-thinning drug does.

(A) prevents blood clots just as well as a commonly used and more expensive blood-thinning drug does
(B) prevents blood clots just as well as does a commonly used and a more expensive blood-thinning drug
(C) prevents blood clots just as well as will a commonly used and more expensive blood-thinning drug
(D) works just as well as a commonly used and more expensive blood-thinning drug at the prevention of blood clots
(E) works just as well as does a commonly used blood-thinning drug, which is also more expensive, at preventing blood clots




Ans: A

我以為是 prevent... from...; (D) 有什麼缺陷嗎?

[iambear2320]

D有點多此一舉吧?
prevent blood clots就好了 不需要再寫成works at the prevention of blood clots ?

[b90702098]

D除了較為wordy
works ....at the prevention的意思與prevents 亦不同
前者指"在預防血管阻塞這方面來說，aspirin的效用跟一般用的藥一樣好"
後者指"aspirin預防阻塞的成效跟一般用的藥一樣好"
後者直接多了







請指教

[autumn713]

(A) prevents blood clots just as well as a commonly used and more expensive blood-thinning drug does
(B) prevents blood clots just as well as does a commonly used and a more expensive blood-thinning drug

a commonly used and more expensive blood-thinning drug
vs.
a commonly used and a more expensive blood-thinning drug
選的時後沒注意到 a 的差別　因為does在前面　所以選了B
但簡討的時後發現a 的差別

後者多加一個a...是不是會讓人覺的有兩種藥效果都跟阿思批零一樣好??
除此　還有沒其它不能加a的原因嗎

Thanks a lot.

[dibert8]

(B) 裡的 drug 是單數

[edas9101]

(A) prevents blood clots just as well as a commonly used and more expensive blood-thinning drug does
(B) prevents blood clots just as well as does a commonly used and a more expensive blood-thinning drug

a commonly used and more expensive blood-thinning drug
vs.
a commonly used and a more expensive blood-thinning drug
選的時後沒注意到 a 的差別　因為does在前面　所以選了B
但簡討的時後發現a 的差別

後者多加一個a...是不是會讓人覺的有兩種藥效果都跟阿思批零一樣好??
除此　還有沒其它不能加a的原因嗎

Thanks a lot.

我有點還是不懂不能加a的原因
感恩

[edas9101]

看懂了
會視為2種藥，a commonly used drug，a more expensive drug
是這樣嗎??

[拎]

請問一下如果這題的B選項沒有後面那個a, 是不是就應該選B了呢?? 第二個as後面的句子要倒裝?? 還是第二個as後面直接加名詞就可以了, 不用再加助動詞?? 比較的題目有時真令我頭痛

[yilingsky]

請問一下如果這題的B選項沒有後面那個a, 是不是就應該選B了呢?? 第二個as後面的句子要倒裝?? 還是第二個as後面直接加名詞就可以了, 不用再加助動詞?? 比較的題目有時真令我頭痛

比較級很複雜, 因此,我舉最常出現的類型來說明:

在比較的主詞不相同的時候, 比較級有三變化:
Even though American Sign Language is the nation's fourth most widely used language, nonverbal communication is still less comprehensive than verbal communication is.
=-------------------------- than verbal communication.(省略V.)
=-------------------------- than is verbal communication.(倒裝V.)

但是要注意:
在AT中常考, 何時補出助動詞/bev?
(1) 主詞 在比較, 且其後有"受詞"時, 要補出助動詞/bev, 避免雙重語意
ex: I eat apple faster than you do.
若少了do, "會變成 吃apple比吃you快"

(2) 主詞 在比較, 且其後有"受詞"時, 可不補出助動詞/bev, 通常已達簡潔
ex: I earn more than you.

例題如下:
pp2-132. (31781-!-item-!-188;#058&006523)
A study published in the British Medical Journal showed that women who ate nuts more than five times a week were about one third less likely to suffer from coronary heart disease as those who ate no nuts at all.

(A) as those who ate
(B) as women who ate
(C) as those eating
(D) than women eating
(E) than were those who ate

答案:E

[拎]

請問一下如果這題的B選項沒有後面那個a, 是不是就應該選B了呢?? 第二個as後面的句子要倒裝?? 還是第二個as後面直接加名詞就可以了, 不用再加助動詞?? 比較的題目有時真令我頭痛

比較級很複雜, 因此,我舉最常出現的類型來說明:

在比較的主詞不相同的時候, 比較級有三變化:
Even though American Sign Language is the nation's fourth most widely used language, nonverbal communication is still less comprehensive than verbal communication is.
=-------------------------- than verbal communication.(省略V.)
=-------------------------- than is verbal communication.(倒裝V.)

但是要注意:
在AT中常考, 何時補出助動詞/bev?
(1) 主詞 在比較, 且其後有"受詞"時, 要補出助動詞/bev, 避免雙重語意
ex: I eat apple faster than you do.
若少了do, "會變成 吃apple比吃you快"

(2) 主詞 在比較, 且其後有"受詞"時, 可不補出助動詞/bev, 通常已達簡潔
ex: I earn more than you.

例題如下:
pp2-132. (31781-!-item-!-188;#058&006523)
A study published in the British Medical Journal showed that women who ate nuts more than five times a week were about one third less likely to suffer from coronary heart disease as those who ate no nuts at all.

(A) as those who ate
(B) as women who ate
(C) as those eating
(D) than women eating
(E) than were those who ate

答案:E

謝謝您的解釋!! 那請問針對as....as....的句型呢???

[CUGGYER]

關於as....as....的句型，助動詞是否提前應該都可以(OG無論是否提前都視為正確的選項)，B選項主要還是and 的後面多出一個 a，把一個藥變成兩個藥，改變句意。

[Philosophia]

在AT中常考, 何時補出助動詞/bev?
(1) 主詞 在比較, 且其後有"受詞"時, 要補出助動詞/bev, 避免雙重語意
ex: I eat apple faster than you do.
若少了do, "會變成 吃apple比吃you快"

(2) 主詞 在比較, 且其後有"受詞"時, 可不補出助動詞/bev, 通常已達簡潔
ex: I earn more than you.

請問 (2) 是否為其後沒有"受詞"的筆誤?

看了你的說明，終於了解OG(VR)106了，謝謝～