[問題]Prep-T2-Q114

[Kal-El]

114. (30375-!-item-!-188;#058&005280)

While Hans Holbein the Younger is most often identified with his English portraits, scholars have long been recognizing him as a superb draftsman and a remarkably versatile artist and who was fundamental in synthesizing the novelties of the Italian Renaissance with the rational tradition of Northern Europe.

(A) been recognizing him as a superb draftsman and a remarkably versatile artist and who
(B) been recognizing him for being a superb draftsman and a remarkably versatile artist and he
(C) recognized him as a superb draftsman and a remarkably versatile artist who
(D) recognized him as a superb draftsman and a remarkably versatile artist and he
(E) recognized him for being a superb draftsman and a remarkably versatile artist and who
Ans: C
請問D為何錯呢?

[dibert8]

(D) 的 he 指代不清 (= artist? draftsman?)
(C) who = artist

[Kal-El]

由代N之一致性
he所代=him所代
所以D之he也代"Hans Holbein the Younger"
醬不可以嗎?

謝～

[dibert8]

這一題,相信很多老美是直奔答案.而我們考 GMAT 難免遇到選項雖然講得過去,為什麼答案不是它?
如果站在 and he 的結構來看,句子變成 scholars... and he... 平衡,讀幾次以後發現 he 在這兒蠻突兀,原因是句意上和 scholars 不對等.
有這種二選一的捆擾出現時,不妨回頭看看選項 (A) 長的樣子,會增加答對的機率.