[問題]Fei Fei #63

[shena]

Some good cooks are gourmet cooks who pride themselves on always using extravagantly rich ingredients in elaborate recipes. Some good cooks can be characterized as fast-food cooks. They may use rich ingredients as long as the recipes are easy to follow and take little time. Other good cooks are health food enthusiasts, who are concerned primarily with the nutritional value of food. But even though not all good cooks are big eaters, they all enjoy preparing and serving food.
If the information in the passage is true, which one of the following CANNOT be true?

(A) Most good cooks do not use extravagantly rich ingredients.
(B) Everyone who enjoys preparing and serving food is a good cook.
(C) More good cooks who use extravagantly rich ingredients are big eaters than are good cooks who do not use such ingredients.
(D) There are fewer good cooks who enjoy serving and preparing food than there are good cooks who are big eaters.
(E) Gourmet cooks, fast-food cooks, and cooks who are health food enthusiasts are all big eaters.

Ans:(D)

這題基本上完全看不懂~不過還是提出我的疑問
題目要選錯誤答案 我覺得很多答案好像都有錯耶

(B)=>題目最後是說good cooks -> enjoy preparing and serving food
但選項(B)是由右邊推導回左邊 Everyone who enjoys preparing and serving food is a good cook.降不是錯的嗎?
(C)=>不知道是從哪一點看出來兩種cook可以比較的?
(E)=>這個結論也很奇怪

明白這題的大大請幫忙囉 ~

[liwuu]

這一題依我的感覺來看,若是要選一個答案,的確D是明顯錯誤的答案
至於其他選項,則存在可能正確或可能錯誤的空間

ps.不過我覺得這種題型應該不會在AT考試中出現...這種比較像是在LSAT的考題!!

[micht]

Some good cooks are gourmet cooks who pride themselves on always using extravagantly rich ingredients in elaborate recipes. Some good cooks can be characterized as fast-food cooks. They may use rich ingredients as long as the recipes are easy to follow and take little time. Other good cooks are health food enthusiasts, who are concerned primarily with the nutritional value of food. But even though not all good cooks are big eaters, they all enjoy preparing and serving food.

If the information in the passage is true, which one of the following CANNOT be true?

(A) Most good cooks do not use extravagantly rich ingredients.
(note 1. most>some)
(B) Everyone who enjoys preparing and serving food is a good cook.
(note 5)
(C) More good cooks who use extravagantly rich ingredients are big eaters than are good cooks who do not use such ingredients. (可能 note 1, 1b, 4)
(D) There are[s] fewer [/s]good cooks who enjoy serving and preparing food than there are good cooks who are big eaters. (note 5)
(E) Gourmet cooks, fast-food cooks, and cooks who are health food enthusiasts are all big eaters. (可能)

Ans:(D)

題中都是以"Some, others, not all, all"部分cooks作比較
all=some Gourmet cooks+some fast-food cooks+other health good enthusiasts cooks (之間可能重疊)

1. Some cookers who pride themselves on always using extravagantly rich ingredients in elaborate recipes
1b. Some good cooks can be characterized as fast-food cooks. They may use rich ingredients
2. Some good cooks =fast-food cooks
3. Other good cooks are health food enthusiasts
4. not all good cooks are big eaters
5. they all enjoy preparing and serving food

a bit confusing, but once you list all the differences between all cooks.
The answer to this question will become much more vivid.

[chencraig0227]

我對B選項有很大的意見!! 因為由另外一邊推論也是很明顯的錯誤。

[dibert8]

這題重點在'可能'
只有 (D) 是不可能的,因為所有的廚師 (all) enjoy preparing and serving food.